Work Truck Logo
MenuMENU
SearchSEARCH

Study Shows Only 57% of Contractors Report Vehicle Accidents

New data published reveals that contractors still see significant impacts to their projects and businesses due to fleet operation and maintenance.

August 15, 2023
Study Shows Only 57% of Contractors Report Vehicle Accidents

More than half find that these issues lead to productivity declines and increased insurance costs, while more than one third experience schedule delays and profitability declines.

Photo: Motive/Work Truck

2 min to read


A new study finds contractors can benefit from safer fleet operations, including productivity and profitability gains.

The study exposes the impacts that contractors experience from safety challenges in the operation and maintenance of their vehicles and equipment, and it reveals opportunities for deploying technology to address them. 

Ad Loading...

New data published by Dodge Construction Network, in partnership with Motive, reveals that contractors still see significant impacts to their projects and businesses due to the operation and maintenance of their fleets of vehicles and equipment.

The data comes from “The Safety on the Move: Automated Fleet Management and the Future of Safety for Contractors.”

Key findings include:

  • Vehicles: Accidents and near-misses are reported by 57% of contractors. More than half find that these issues lead to productivity declines and increased insurance costs, while more than one third experience schedule delays and profitability declines.

  • Equipment: While accidents and near misses for equipment are reported by fewer contractors (27%), they more frequently result, i.e. negative impacts on productivity and schedule. In fact, 60% of those who experience them link them directly to a decline in profitability on their projects.

  • Maintenance: 66% of contractors also experience safety issues due to the need for improved fleet maintenance, including both vehicles and equipment.

Streamlining and Supervising in Fleet

The research also uncovers a significant opening for contractors to streamline the monitoring and supervising their fleet safety through automation.

Ad Loading...

The results demonstrate that while 76% of contractors oversee vehicle safety and 62% monitor driver behavior, most still use physical forms or spreadsheets for these tasks.

Merely a quarter (25%) have automated the collection of driver behavior data, and an even smaller fraction (18%) have automated their fleet safety tracking.

Similar patterns emerge in fleet maintenance, where only a quarter (25%) incorporate automation or AI to facilitate management processes.

However, the study highlights that 80% of those employing technology in this aspect witness enhanced safety levels in their projects.

“Too often, safety is seen as a compliance requirement and not what it really is: a key element of a company’s operations that benefits the bottom line, and more importantly protects people, property and reputation,” says Abhishek Gupta, vice president of Product for Fleet Management at Motive. “The improved working conditions, efficiency, and cost savings that come with making safety a priority mean it should be a primary consideration for any business operating in the physical economy.”

The Power of Predictive Analytics: Turning Data into Decisions

More Safety

Graphic featuring fireworks on a blue background with the headline "Stay Safe on the Road This July 4th" and the subheading "Tips From a Former Truck Driver." The image promotes road safety during holiday travel and accompanies advice on avoiding truck blind spots, passing safely, leaving adequate space around trucks, and planning travel during busy traffic periods.
Safetyby StaffJune 18, 2026

5 Safe Driving Tips for 4th of July

To ensure that this year’s fireworks remain in the sky and not on the roadway, follow these five easy steps to remain safe on the road this year – shared directly from a truck driver.

Read More →
Graphic for NSC National Safety Month featuring warehouse, trucking, and transportation workers. Text highlights safety priorities including moving safety forward, road safety, worker health, and preventing slips, trips, and falls.
Safetyby StaffJune 16, 2026

NSC Marks 30 Years of National Safety Month, Includes Road Safety Focus

The Staying Safe on the Roads topic is one of four weekly focuses in June as the National Safety Council observes the 30th anniversary of National Safety Month. NSC also provides insights on the need for fleets to create a safety policy.

Read More →
Person using a laptop to view a fleet management dashboard displaying weather alerts, vehicle speed data, maps, and road-condition images. The screen highlights a snowy roadway and a lake-effect snow warning for a fleet vehicle.
Safetyby News/Media ReleaseJune 12, 2026

Fleetworthy Integrates Lytx Video Snapshots to Improve Driver Coaching

Fleetworthy’s integration of Lytx video snapshots enables fleet managers to combine visual event evidence with Safety+ risk data, helping them make faster, more informed coaching decisions without leaving the Fleetworthy platform.

Read More →
Ad Loading...
Graphic showing the word “RECALL” painted in large yellow letters across a road surface with double yellow center lines. “June” appears at top left, and the Work Truck logo appears at bottom right.
Safetyby Wayne ParhamJune 10, 2026

Recalls You Need to Know About in June 2026

In June 2026, what recalls might impact your fleet? Work Truck has the answers in this comprehensive overview of recent NHTSA recalls.

Read More →
J. J. Keller & Associates, Inc. Safety Professional of the Year award logo, featuring the company name, stylized “K” emblem, and bold “SPOTY” acronym above the title “Safety Professional of the Year.”
Safetyby News/Media ReleaseJune 8, 2026

J. J. Keller Safety Professional of the Year Awards Nominations Now Open

J. J. Keller & Associates is accepting nominations for the 2026 J. J. Keller Safety Professional of the Year (SPOTY) Awards. Winners will receive prize packages valued at up to $47,200.

Read More →
A wide promotional graphic announcing changes to Automotive Service Professionals Month. The ASE Automotive Service Professionals Month logo appears above text announcing that beginning in 2026-2027, Automotive Service Professionals Month will move to April and October to align with Spring and Fall Car Care Months.
Safetyby Lauren FletcherJune 2, 2026

ASE Aligns Automotive Service Professionals Month With Spring and Fall Vehicle Maintenance Campaigns

ASE will move Automotive Service Professionals Month to April and October beginning in 2026-2027, aligning recognition with Car Care Month events.

Read More →
Ad Loading...
wheel geotab image
SponsoredJune 1, 2026

Turning Connected Vehicle Data Into Decisions That Matter

Fleet leaders have more data than ever, but turning that data into clear, actionable decisions remains a challenge. This white paper shows how leading organizations are using connected vehicle data to improve safety, reduce costs, and optimize fleet performance. Learn how to turn insight into action across your fleet.

Read More →
Presenter onstage at Motive Vision 26 conference beside a large smartphone display showing a driver rewards app, highlighting a first-place achievement in a Q1 Excellence Program with points, rankings, and Google Pay integration.
Safetyby Wayne ParhamMay 29, 2026

Driver Retention: Motive Automates Driver Coaching & Driver Rewards

New automated rewards and recognition capabilities from Motive can help organizations engage drivers, reinforce positive behavior, and reduce turnover. AI Coach has also been updated to deliver personalized feedback across safety, fuel, and compliance.

Read More →
Graphic for Work Truck’s 2026 Wildfire Outlook featuring bold white text over an active forest wildfire scene, with flames spreading across wooded terrain against a red-orange sky.
Disaster Responseby Wayne ParhamMay 27, 2026

Experts Forecast Broader Impact of Wildfires in 2026

This year’s wildfire season will likely be more intense than in 2025. The 2026 wildfire forecast from AccuWeather is for fewer fires, but even more acreage will be impacted this year.

Read More →
Ad Loading...
Graphic featuring a speech bubble with the text “DataQs?” centered between two white semi-trucks on a textured brown background, with the Work Truck logo in the upper left corner.
Safetyby Kathy CloseMay 26, 2026

A Walkthrough of the DataQs Process

Bad data on your carrier record can cost you. Here’s how DataQs helps fleets challenge errors before they hit CSA scores, insurance, and your bottom line.

Read More →