Work Truck Logo
MenuMENU
SearchSEARCH

Ford F-150 Takes Top Spot in Kbb.com Full-Size Pickup Truck Comparison Test

IRVINE, CA - The Ford F-150 took the top spot in an all-new full-size pickup comparison test, 'First to Worst: Kbb.com Ranks Five Full-Size Pickups,' by the expert editors from Kelley Blue Book www.kbb.com, a provider of new car and used car information.

by Staff
July 7, 2010
4 min to read


IRVINE, CA - The Ford F-150 took the top spot in an all-new full-size pickup comparison test, 'First to Worst: Kbb.com Ranks Five Full-Size Pickups,' by the expert editors from Kelley Blue Bookwww.kbb.com, a provider of new car and used car information.

Ad Loading...

The kbb.com editors lauded the F-150 not only because it was outstanding in all areas, but because it offered a well-rounded, thoroughly developed package that does everything to a high standard, saying "If you can't find something here to suit your fancy, you need to look again."  In addition to winning high marks in driving dynamics due to its enhanced level of ride and handling, the kbb.com editors praised the F-150 for both its exterior and interior styling, noting that it strikes "a nice blend of the style and function that should define a pickup."  The F-150 also scored well because it is the only pickup in the segment to offer Roll Stability Control as standard, coupled with its AdvanceTrac electronic stability control.

Ad Loading...

For years, the best-selling vehicles in America were full-size pickup trucks, led by the Ford F-150.  Even now, with fuel costs pinching family finances, pickups are still very popular, and not just with those buyers who need utility for work.  Much of pickups' appeal with buyers is based as much on image as function, yet they continue to roll off the assembly lines, onto showroom floors and into driveways.  As such, the kbb.com editors took a look at five popular full-size pickups, excluding the various "Heavy Duty" or "Super Duty" models (which are really intended for harder work and heavier loads), put them through a comprehensive comparison test and ultimately ranked them from 'first to worst.'

The market offers five full-size pickups, all of which were tested by the kbb.com editorial team.  Alphabetically, they are: Chevrolet Silverado 1500, Ford F-150, Nissan Titan, Ram 1500 (formerly Dodge, but now known as "just Ram") and Toyota Tundra.  All are available in a variety of cab configurations and cargo-bed lengths, engine selections and two or four-wheel drive.  All also offer ranges of trim levels and features and can be optioned up to very luxurious accommodations.

"America's love affair with the pickup truck continues and rightfully so, with today's new pickups often offering amenities comparable to luxury vehicles while simultaneously providing the rugged functionality of a truck," said Jack R. Nerad, executive editorial director and executive market analyst for Kelley Blue Book's kbb.com.  "After the kbb.com editorial team's rigorous testing, the Ford F-150 emerged as the clear winner in this comparison, proving it undoubtedly deserves top status among full-size pickups."

After driving and spending time with all five pickups, the editors sat down and scored them in a variety of categories.  In addition, each member of the kbb.com editorial team also ranked, on a scale of 0-10, the likelihood of recommending each truck to a friend.

This gave both a comprehensive, mathematically crunched and objective rating of the trucks, and a subjective rating of which vehicle each editor rated the best overall.  The comprehensive comparison tests conducted by the entire kbb.com editorial staff included scoring multiple points of consideration for each vehicle in each of the following categories: exterior, interior, driving dynamics, safety (both active and passive safety), crash ratings, and value (examining both New Car Blue Book Values, which are the actual transaction values of what each vehicle is currently selling for, as well as projected future resale values).  In addition, for each of the full-size pickups, the editors identified strengths, shortcomings, along with detailed paragraphs about their experiences in each vehicle.  

Ad Loading...

When all the numbers were tabulated the rankings from the objective, categorical scoring matched the rankings from the subjective ratings. The end-result is an extremely comprehensive view of the full-size truck segment in the United States, loaded with important information for anyone who may be in the market for a new pickup.  

To see the full rankings of the five pickups from 'first to worst' along with all of the aforementioned scores and details from the expert editors of Kelley Blue Book's kbb.com, visit the 'First to Worst: Kbb.com Ranks Five Full-Size Pickups' story in kbb.com's Latest News section at http://kbb.us/2010pickups.

More Operations

Work Truck leadership update graphic featuring Alan Wiessbrod, Teletrac Navman senior vice president of operations and enterprise transformation, alongside his portrait on a blue background.
Operationsby News/Media ReleaseSeptember 21, 2026

Teletrac Navman Hires SVP of Operations & Enterprise Transformation

Teletrac Navman has appointed Alan Wiessbrod to its senior leadership team as senior vice president, operations and enterprise transformation. The company said he has a strong track record of delivering profitable growth and operational excellence.

Read More →
Work Truck Weekly Truck Chat Cheat Sheet thumbnail featuring Lauren Fletcher beside bold text reading “2027 GM Trucks, Tech Retention & Fleet Lessons,” with a semi-truck in the background.
Operationsby Lauren FletcherSeptember 21, 2026

2027 GM Trucks, Technician Retention, and Fleet Lessons Lead This Week’s News

New GM pickups, technician retention, fleet leadership lessons, winter equipment, and more headline this week’s Truck Chat Weekly Cheat Sheet.

Read More →
Shades of Fleet “Family Ties” thumbnail with Lauren Fletcher, a family tree graphic, keys, and Work Truck branding.
Operationsby Lauren FletcherSeptember 15, 2026

Family Ties Inside the Fleet Families Building Careers Across Generations

Three fleet families share what it really takes to work together, learn across generations, and keep business from following them home.

Read More →
Ad Loading...
Shades of Fleet Hidden Heroes graphic featuring silhouetted dispatchers, coordinators, parts specialists, and support staff working across fleet operations, with a Share Your Story callout.
Operationsby Lauren FletcherSeptember 15, 2026

Shades of Fleet Call for Voices: Fleet's Hidden Heroes

Fleet’s hidden heroes are often the ones keeping everything moving behind the scenes. September’s Shades of Fleet is looking for dispatchers, coordinators, parts specialists, and other support pros to share their stories.

Read More →
Truck Centers Inc. graphic recognizing National Truck Driver Appreciation Week, Sept. 14–18, over an image of a semi-truck traveling along a rural highway beneath a cloudy sky.
Operationsby News/Media ReleaseSeptember 14, 2026

Truck Centers, Inc. Celebrates National Truck Driver Appreciation Week with $1,000 Fuel Card Giveaways

During National Truck Driver Appreciation Week, Truck Centers, Inc. is offering customers a chance to fuel up for free. Customers at all Truck Centers locations can enter to win one of four $1,000 fuel cards from Sept. 14 - 18.

Read More →
Lauren Fletcher appears in a Work Truck Weekly Truck Chat Cheat Sheet thumbnail with bold blue, black, white, and orange graphics. Text highlights fleet guides, AI, tariffs, and fuel strategy, with a semi-truck in the background.
Operationsby Lauren FletcherSeptember 14, 2026

Fleet Guides, AI Time-Savers, Truck Tariffs & Fuel Strategy Lead the News

This week’s Truck Chat Cheat Sheet covers new fleet vehicle guides, practical AI use cases, U.S.-Canada truck production, mixed-energy strategy, and more.

Read More →
Ad Loading...
Podcast cover for “The Fleet Skills We Keep Missing on Veterans’ Resumes” featuring a folded American flag, military dog tags, a resume listing leadership and adaptability skills, a wrench, and vehicle keys on a dark workbench.
OperationsSeptember 11, 2026

What Fleet Employers Are Missing When Hiring Veterans

What if some of the strongest candidates for fleet are already out there, but their experience is written in a language our industry does not always recognize?

Read More →
Leadership update graphic announcing Ricardo Buranello as chief executive officer of Teletrac Navman, featuring Buranello speaking into a microphone alongside the Work Truck logo.
Operationsby News/Media ReleaseSeptember 9, 2026

Teletrac Navman Promotes New CEO from Within

Teletrac Navman’s next CEO, Ricardo Buranello, has served as the company’s chief financial and operating officer. He brings deep financial and operational expertise, a strong strategic orientation, and an intimate knowledge of the business to his new role.

Read More →
Graphic promoting Automotive Fleet's 2026 Personal Use Survey with the text "Have a Personal Use Policy? We Want to Know!" encouraging fleet managers to complete the annual industry survey.
Operationsby StaffSeptember 8, 2026

Automotive Fleet Opens 2026 Personal Use Survey for Commercial Fleet Managers

Less than two weeks left! Commercial and corporate fleet managers are invited to share how their organizations handle company vehicle personal-use policies, charges, and driver eligibility.

Read More →
Ad Loading...
Truck Chat promotional graphic featuring two hosts and the headline “Operate Fleet at the Speed of Business,” presented by Work Truck.
Operationsby Lauren FletcherSeptember 7, 2026

What Resilient Fleets Do Differently When Conditions Change

Fleet resilience is about more than reacting to disruption. Lauren Fletcher talks with AP Fleet’s Alex Coveney about flexibility, planning, scaling, and what helps fleets adapt when business conditions shift.

Read More →