When it comes to keeping your fleet drivers safe, not all trucks are created equal. New research from iSeeCars, using data from the National Highway Traffic Safety Administration’s Fatality Analysis Reporting System (FARS), takes a hard look at fatal accident rates among popular midsize and full-size trucks. 

The results highlight some surprising trends. While trucks are often seen as safer because of their size and build, the data shows that smaller trucks, in particular, might not live up to that reputation.

As a fleet manager, understanding which vehicles have higher risks can help you make smarter choices when it’s time to add or replace trucks in your lineup. Here’s what you need to know about which trucks performed best, and worst, when it comes to protecting their occupants in serious crashes.

Top Pickup Trucks with the Highest Fatal Accident Rates

The analysis focused on fatal crashes involving model-year 2018-2022 trucks. The average fatal accident rate for trucks was 2.3 fatalities per billion vehicle miles. 

Here's how specific models stacked up:

1. Nissan Frontier – Leading the list, the Frontier’s fatal accident rate was 5.0, more than double the average.

2. Ford Ranger – At 4.0, the Ranger's rate was 1.7 times higher than average.

3. Chevrolet Colorado – With a fatality rate of 2.9, the Colorado narrowly exceeded the average.

4. Toyota Tacoma – Performing slightly better, the Tacoma’s rate stood at 2.8.

5. Jeep Gladiator – The Gladiator rounded out the list with a rate of 2.7.

While midsize trucks like the Nissan Frontier and Ford Ranger performed poorly compared to the segment average, most full-size trucks outperformed their smaller counterparts. 

Taking a Look at the Larger Picture

Karl Brauer, Executive Analyst at iSeeCars, explained, “Even within the truck category, the 'larger vehicle wins' trend holds true. Full-size trucks tend to protect occupants better, likely because of their increased size and weight. However, as the data shows, midsize trucks often lag behind in safety performance.”

For fleet managers, understanding these fatality statistics is crucial when selecting vehicles. While midsize trucks may offer better fuel efficiency and maneuverability, safety considerations should also play a role in decision-making. Be sure to weigh the advantages of full-size trucks against the risks associated with smaller models.

So, what are the most dangerous midsize trucks for fleet safety? The iSeeCars study found that the Nissan Frontier and Ford Ranger have the highest fatal accident rates among midsize trucks, with the Frontier at 5.0 fatalities per billion vehicle miles, over twice the average for trucks.

Stay ahead of fleet trends! Subscribe to our newsletter for the latest news, expert tips, and insights tailored for fleet professionals. Sign up today!

About the Research

iSeeCars analyzed extensive fatality data from 2017-2022 to calculate fatal accident rates. The study adjusted for exposure by normalizing the number of crashes by vehicle miles driven, offering a clear view of which vehicles pose the most risk to occupants.