Work Truck Logo
MenuMENU
SearchSEARCH

5 Differences Between Grandfathered AOBRDs and ELDs

Training on the operational differences between AOBRDs and ELDs is a critical component of the plan to help reduce the frustrations your drivers and operations department may experience on the first few days of your ELD launch.

Kathy Close
Kathy CloseCompliance Expert at J.J. Keller
Read Kathy's Posts
June 24, 2019
5 Differences Between Grandfathered AOBRDs and ELDs

An inspector shows a driver how to transfer his hours of service log at roadside – something that you have to be able to do with ELDs that you didn't with AOBRDs.

Photo courtesy CVSA

3 min to read


Motor carriers operating grandfathered automatic onboard recording devices (AOBRDs) to record their drivers’ hours of service must switch to an approved electronic logging device (ELD) by Dec. 16, 2019.

Ad Loading...

With little time remaining, carriers that want to minimize stress should plan to make the change sooner rather than later. Training on the operational differences between AOBRDs and ELDs is a critical component of the plan to help reduce the frustrations that your drivers and operations department may experience on the first few days of your ELD launch.

Ad Loading...

Some of the more significant differences include: 

1. Log-in Procedures 

When a driver logs into an ELD, he or she is prompted to accept or reject unassigned driving time on the device. Any accepted time is integrated into the driver’s records. Rejected time must be addressed by the back office by either assigning it to a specific driver or explaining through an attached comment why it could not be assigned.

AOBRDs, on the other hand, do not require annotation of the unassigned driving time when it cannot be attributed to a specific driver. The time could be attributed, instead, to a ghost account, which is not allowed with an ELD. 

2. Driving Status

AOBRDs allow the motor carrier to determine when an event is defined as driving (based on speed and distance traveled). But ELDs are more stringent and programmed to switch to the driving status when the vehicle reaches up to 5 mph unless the driver selects one of two categories: personal use or yard moves. 

Typically, when using these two categories while operating an AOBRD, drivers must log out of the device and then edit the time as on-duty, not driving.  

Ad Loading...

Fewer data entry errors equate to fewer roadside inspection violations, minimizing the effect on your company’s safety record. 

3. Editing Options

Unlike AOBRDs, an ELD system provides drivers with full editing rights, except for the automatic recording of all drive time. All other entries must be editable by the driver. Also, any edits made in the back office must be approved by the driver before becoming a part of his or her record.

Editing topics to reinforce with drivers include:

  • Acceptable/unacceptable edits,

  • How to make edits, and 

  • How to accept or reject back-office edits.

4. Data Transfer

During a roadside inspection, ELD log data is transferred directly to the officer. Drivers are expected to know the device’s transfer method (telematic or local transfer) and how to use the options within the method. The officer has the option of asking the driver to display or print the logs.

With AOBRDs, the driver is only required to show the officer the display. If the officer wants a copy of the records, the driver or carrier has up to 48 hours to provide them through any means.

Ad Loading...

In the event of a DOT audit, back-office personnel must be trained on this same ELD data transfer method. An investigator will expect a carrier to forward the ELD records using one of the transfer methods.

5. Generic Accounts

ELD systems do not allow for the use of generic or “ghost” accounts. Each account must have an actual person assigned to it, except for the unassigned driving time account. Driver accounts must include the driver’s license number to validate the driver. This means that carriers need to develop procedures for dealing with movements made by drivers without ELD accounts, sich as mechanics or supervisors. 

Create A Comfort Level Beforehand

Employees should be introduced to the equipment and its features before the day of conversion. This familiarity with your ELD will help reduce the number of entry errors. Fewer errors equate to fewer roadside inspection violations, minimizing the effect on your company’s safety record. 

Subscribe to Our Newsletter

More Safety & Compliance

Work Truck graphic with “Fall Back” and “Keep Fleet Safety in Focus” over a sunlit field, with a clock illustration on the right.
Safety & Compliance•by Lauren Fletcher•October 30, 2026

Navigating the Effects of Daylight Saving Time on Work Truck Fleets

Discover how daylight saving time impacts work truck fleets and get essential tips for fleet managers and drivers to navigate the "fall back" transition.

Read More →
Three glowing jack-o’-lanterns beneath a full moon, with silhouetted trees and gravestones. Text reads “Keeping Your Drivers Safe?” above the Work Truck logo.
Safety & Compliance•by Lauren Fletcher•October 29, 2026

How Halloween Changes the Job for Work Truck Drivers

Truck traffic doesn’t take the same Halloween break as other drivers. What fleet managers should know about timing, neighborhood stops, and braking data.

Read More →
Safe Driving on Halloween over spooky fall road
Safety & Compliance•by Staff•October 25, 2026

Tips for Driving Safely on Halloween Night

This video features a reminder from the Connecticut Department of Transportation (DOT) and the Connecticut Police Chiefs Association, urging drivers to prioritize safety this Halloween.

Read More →
Ad Loading...
Work Truck graphic with a truck engine and the text “Rerating GVWR — What Fleets Need to Know.”
Safety & Compliance•by Staff•October 22, 2026

Re-rating Gross Vehicle Weight Ratings (GVWR): Why and How it's Done

Sometimes, it is not in a fleet’s best interests to have a vehicle at a given GVWR. Changing the GVWR to a special value can be done, but the process is complicated.

Read More →
Work gloves, a hard hat, tablet, keys, and paperwork sit on a workbench beside a calendar marked “Out of Service,” illustrating the operational disruption caused by a missing work truck.
Safety & Compliance•October 22, 2026

When a Work Truck Gets Stolen, the Real Loss Is Time

A stolen work truck can take more than a vehicle off the road. From tools and access cards to crew downtime, here’s how fleets can prepare for theft before it disrupts the entire workday.

Read More →
Ten members of the America's Road Team pose in front of a white Volvo semi-truck featuring patriotic graphics and the America's Road Team logo at the MCE26 conference and exhibition.
Safety & Compliance•by News/Media Release•October 21, 2026

Volvo Trucks Marks 25 Years as Exclusive Sponsor of America's Road Team

Volvo Trucks North America will serve as the exclusive sponsor of the American Trucking Associations' America's Road Team, marking 25 years of Volvo sponsorship. The group of professional drivers promotes safety and the industry as they travel the country.

Read More →
Ad Loading...
Streamlight Portable Scene Light III displayed on a tripod with a close-up of its LED light head, alongside a badge recognizing it as the 2026 OH&S New Product of the Year winner.
Safety & Compliance•by News/Media Release•October 21, 2026

Streamlight’s High-Output Scene Light Recognized with Occupational Safety Award

Streamlight’s Portable Scene Light III (PSL III) won the 2026 Occupational Health & Safety (OH&S) New Product of the Year Award in the Lighting category.

Read More →
Fleetworthy Expedited Inspection graphic featuring a commercial vehicle inspector walking toward a white semi-truck, with tablet and smartphone displays showing digital driver vehicle examination reports.
Safety & Compliance•by News/Media Release•October 14, 2026

Fleetworthy Expands Expedited Inspection to 5 States

Following its industry-first launch in Nevada, Fleetworthy’s automated inspection technology is now live in California, Michigan, Vermont, and Maine.

Read More →
Red and Black Promo graphic with Kathy Close of JJ Keller that says Behind the Article, Under 26,001 lbs.? IRP May still apply.
Safety & Compliance•by Lauren Fletcher•October 12, 2026

Crossing State Lines in a Light-Duty Work Truck? Check These Rules First

Crossing state lines in a lighter work truck? J.J. Keller's Kathy Close explains when IRP registration, trip permits, and towing rules come into play.

Read More →
Ad Loading...
Safety & Compliance•by Staff•October 12, 2026

Simple Tire Checks That Help Keep Your Business Fleet Moving

A survey found that nearly one in every 10 passenger vehicles has at least one bald tire. What's more, 27% -- more than one in four -- of vehicles are driven with one or more severely under-inflated tires.

Read More →