What’s the Origin of the Halloween Potato?
Well… it depends on who you ask. There are a few stories floating around, but based on what I researched, here are the two most likely:
According to the The Economic Times and a recent release from Potatoes USA on Business Wire, a Pennsylvania contractor named Pat Foy, now affectionately known as The Potato Man, began handing out potatoes to trick-or-treaters nearly two decades ago. What started as a lighthearted joke (“I’m of Irish descent, so potatoes made sense,” he told reporters) quickly became a hometown tradition.
Kids in Lancaster now line up at his door every year for their annual spud stop, so much so that when the pandemic hit, Foy even built a potato chute out of PVC pipe to deliver them from a distance.
And he’s not the only one. The Economic Times notes that the trend spread far beyond Pennsylvania. In Anchorage, Alaska, pastor Matt Schultz joined in, offering trick-or-treaters a choice between candy and a potato. His #ChoosePotato post went viral after thousands of kids gleefully picked the spud over sweets.
Even OnMilwaukee traced its own local “potato house” back to 2022, when a homeowner put out a bowl of candy and a bag of raw russets, and dozens of kids chose the potato instead.
So while there’s no single “official” origin story, the common thread is clear: what started as a simple, funny twist on tradition became a moment of unexpected joy that spread across neighborhoods, one potato at a time.
Will you be adding potatoes to your candy dish next year?