Work Truck Logo
MenuMENU
SearchSEARCH

Ford F-150 Ranks Top in KBB.com Full-Size Truck Comparison Test

IRVINE, CA - The Ford F-150 took the top spot in an all-new full-size pickup comparison test, 'First to Worst: Kbb.com Ranks Five Full-Size Pickups.

by Staff
June 23, 2010
4 min to read


IRVINE, CA - The Ford F-150 took the top spot in an all-new full-size pickup comparison test, 'First to Worst: Kbb.com Ranks Five Full-Size Pickups,' by the editors from Kelley Blue Bookwww.kbb.com, the leading provider of new car and used car information. 

The kbb.com editors lauded the F-150 not only because it was outstanding in all areas, but because it offered a well-rounded, thoroughly developed package that does everything to a high standard, saying "If you can't find something here to suit your fancy, you need to look again."  In addition to winning high marks in driving dynamics due to its enhanced level of ride and handling, the kbb.com editors praised the F-150 for both its exterior and interior styling, noting that it strikes "a nice blend of the style and function that should define a pickup."  The F-150 also scored well because it is the only pickup in the segment to offer Roll Stability Control as standard, coupled with its AdvanceTrac electronic stability control.

Ad Loading...

For years, the best-selling vehicles in America were full-size pickup trucks, led by the Ford F-150.  Even now, with fuel costs pinching family finances, pickups are still very popular, and not just with those buyers who need utility for work.  Much of pickups' appeal with buyers is based as much on image as function, yet they continue to roll off the assembly lines, onto showroom floors and into driveways.  As such, the kbb.com editors took a look at five popular full-size pickups, excluding the various "Heavy Duty" or "Super Duty" models (which are really intended for harder work and heavier loads), put them through a comprehensive comparison test and ultimately ranked them from 'first to worst.'

The market offers five full-size pickups, all of which were tested by the kbb.com editorial team.  Alphabetically, they are: Chevrolet Silverado 1500, Ford F-150, Nissan Titan, Ram 1500 (formerly Dodge, but now known as "just Ram") and Toyota Tundra.  All are available in a variety of cab configurations and cargo-bed lengths, engine selections and two or four-wheel drive.  All also offer ranges of trim levels and features and can be optioned up to very luxurious accommodations.

"America's love affair with the pickup truck continues and rightfully so, with today's new pickups often offering amenities comparable to luxury vehicles while simultaneously providing the rugged functionality of a truck," said Jack R. Nerad, executive editorial director and executive market analyst for Kelley Blue Book's kbb.com.  "After the kbb.com editorial team's rigorous testing, the Ford F-150 emerged as the clear winner in this comparison, proving it undoubtedly deserves top status among full-size pickups."

[PAGEBREAK]

After driving and spending time with all five pickups, the editors sat down and scored them in a variety of categories.  In addition, each member of the kbb.com editorial team also ranked, on a scale of 0-10, the likelihood of recommending each truck to a friend.  This gave both a comprehensive, mathematically crunched and objective rating of the trucks, and a subjective rating of which vehicle each editor rated the best overall.  The comprehensive comparison tests conducted by the entire kbb.com editorial staff included scoring multiple points of consideration for each vehicle in each of the following categories:  exterior, interior, driving dynamics, safety (both active and passive safety), crash ratings, and value (examining both New Car Blue Book Values, which are the actual transaction values of what each vehicle is currently selling for, as well as projected future resale values).  In addition, for each of the full-size pickups, the editors identified strengths, shortcomings, along with detailed paragraphs about their experiences in each vehicle.  When all the numbers were tabulated the rankings from the objective, categorical scoring matched the rankings from the subjective ratings. The end-result is an extremely comprehensive view of the full-size truck segment in the United States, loaded with important information for anyone who may be in the market for a new pickup. 

Ad Loading...

To see the full rankings of the five pickups from 'first to worst' along with all of the aforementioned scores and details from the expert editors of Kelley Blue Book's kbb.com, visit the 'First to Worst: Kbb.com Ranks Five Full-Size Pickups' story in kbb.com's Latest News section at http://kbb.us/2010pickups.

More Operations

Skyline of London with a blue sky and an inset logo for Kooner.
OperationsMay 4, 2026

Kooner Fleet Management Solutions Expands Internationally with Launch in the UK

Kooner Fleet Management Solutions’ new Central England operations hub establishes a foundation for 24/7 fleet maintenance, mobile repair, and technician development across the UK.

Read More →
Host Lauren Fletcher gestures toward “Truck Chat Weekly Cheat Sheet” graphic highlighting driver input, TPMS benefits, and the end of International CV Series production.
Operationsby Lauren FletcherMay 4, 2026

Drivers Speak Up, TPMS Pays Off, and a Workhorse Retires | Weekly Cheat Sheet

Drivers are shaping fleet decisions, TPMS is delivering real savings, and a key workhorse is retiring. Plus quick hits on data, uptime, and new trucks.

Read More →
Graphic illustration of runners' feet on glowing pavement to the right, a big rig truck on the left, and headline for a virtual 5k to benefit truck drivers.
Operationsby News/Media ReleaseMay 1, 2026

St. Christopher Truckers Relief Fund Launches 2nd Annual Virtual 5K to Support Health and Wellness for Professional Drivers

St. Christopher Truckers Relief Fund’s 2nd Annual Virtual 5K raises funds and awareness for over-the-road truck drivers facing illness or injury, and there’s still time to participate in this year’s event.

Read More →
Ad Loading...
Open glowing book on a wooden table with candles, quill, and maps, with golden light and magical particles rising from its pages in a fantasy-style illustration.
Operationsby Lauren FletcherMay 1, 2026

The Future of Storytelling Still Belongs To Humans

New tools always change the process. They do not replace the instinct. From portrait painters adapting to photography to creators navigating AI, the people who matter most are still the ones who know how to see.

Read More →
“Legends of Fleet” featuring a dark textured background with gold accents, large metallic gold title text centered, and a framed portrait of Carl Nelson with subtitle identifying him as a retired fleet manager, along with Work Truck and Legend logos at the top.
OperationsApril 30, 2026

Carl Nelson's Journey, Sliding into Success | Fleet Legends

With more than four decades of experience across fleets such as AT&T and AmeriGas, Carl built a reputation for doing the work, leading through change, and helping to move the industry forward without ever making it about himself.

Read More →
Breakdowns, data & insights are the topics of the April 2026 Truck Chat Monthly Recap sponsored by Chevron REGI
OperationsApril 28, 2026

Breakdowns, Data Action, and Driver Insight Take Center Stage | Truck Chat Monthly April Recap

In this month’s news recap, we’re digging into why trucks are still failing in the field, how fleets are finally turning data into action, why driver feedback is becoming a critical operational tool, how fleet leaders are finding their voice, and where simple tech like TPMS is delivering real results.

Read More →
Ad Loading...
A graphic image showing charts and graphs depicting cargo theft in the first quarter of 2026.
Operationsby News/Media ReleaseApril 27, 2026

Cargo Theft Incident Volume Falls in First Quarter of 2026

Verisk CargoNet reported that supply chain crime events across the United States and Canada declined by 5.3% in the first quarter of 2026. However, confirmed cargo theft reports rose slightly, by 41 incidents.

Read More →
Graphic promoting Work Truck Exchange with bold text highlighting pre-scheduled meetings, limited spots remaining, and event details for Phoenix, Arizona.
Operationsby Lauren FletcherApril 27, 2026

Limited Spots Remain for Fleet Managers to Attend Work Truck Exchange

Limited spots remain for Work Truck Exchange in Phoenix. Fleet managers can connect through pre-scheduled meetings designed to deliver real solutions fast.

Read More →
Lauren Fletcher presenting Truck Chat Weekly Cheat Sheet graphic highlighting breakdowns, data action, and driver feedback trends in fleet operations.
Operationsby Lauren FletcherApril 27, 2026

Why Trucks Keep Failing, Plus Data Action and Driver Feedback

Fleets tackle breakdowns, act on data, and rethink driver feedback. Plus TPMS gains and key industry shifts in this week’s Truck Chat Cheat Sheet.

Read More →
Ad Loading...
Shades of Fleet Veterans in Fleet graphic with American flags and Work Truck branding highlighting military veterans’ impact on fleet leadership and operations
Operationsby Lauren FletcherApril 24, 2026

Call for Voices: Inviting Veterans in Fleet to Share Their Stories

Veterans in fleet, it's your turn! share how military experience shapes leadership, discipline, and real-world decision-making across today’s operations.

Read More →