Work Truck Logo
MenuMENU
SearchSEARCH

Donlen's Strategic Consulting Introduces New Scorecarding

Today’s fleet environment calls for strategic analysis to identify solutions to operational and fiscal issues. Donlen is delivering results with a commitment to customized analyses, fleet-specific benchmarking, and ongoing consultation.

by Staff
April 1, 2008
Donlen's Strategic Consulting Introduces New Scorecarding

Donlen’s strategic consulting team includes (l-r) Dan Hannan, senior VP, strategic consulting & quality; Bob Zimmer, director, reporting architecture; Brad Jacobs, consulting business analyst; Chelsea Mathis, consulting business analyst; and Evan McKerns, strategic consulting leader.

4 min to read



As the responsibility for fleet operations reacts to the involvement of sourcing, finance, and accounting, fleet managers are increasingly challenged to find ways to reduce costs and increase efficiency to achieve organizational objectives. Traditional fleet management practices must be supplemented with a comprehensive understanding of fleet operations, precise analysis, and insight into how fleet behaviors and prevailing trends impact the balance sheet. According to Donlen Corporation, fleet managers should invest their time in making decisions and managing their businesses, instead of gathering and interpreting data. Donlen takes its analytical approach to new levels by providing solutions to clients through its Strategic Consulting Services team.

Ad Loading...

Leveraging industry experience and Strategic Consulting Services’ analytical expertise, Donlen collaborates with clients to develop strategic acquisition and remarketing plans, effectively manage fuel and maintenance expenses, optimize lifecycle planning, and manage fleet’s environmental impact. The process is a partnership between the company and its customers, not only to set strategies, but to manage them on an ongoing basis. According to Donlen, the foundation of the process can be summed up into three words: model, measure, and manage.

Understanding Cost Factors

Evan McKerns, strategic consulting leader at Donlen, presented the goals driving the team’s mission and the consulting process:

“We focus on building and strengthening client relationships through analytical insight and creative solutions to fleet issues. By tracking and monitoring fleet performance, Strategic Consulting provides assistance to clients so they can better understand how their fleet behaviors and policies impact costs.”


Developing a Model


The first step in developing an effective management strategy is to fully rationalize how all the pieces of fleet operations fit together. Donlen leverages a number of proprietary tools in FleetWeb to create comprehensive models, drawing on real-time data to put these pieces together. The core of this modeling stage is Donlen’s Vehicle Optimization Model. Donlen Strategic Consultants create side-by-side graphical comparisons to illustrate the impacts of lease terms, mileages, depreciation rates, new-vehicle pricing, incentives, residual projections, fuel and maintenance costs as well as the environmental impact. All fixed and variable costs are evaluated.

Ad Loading...

The Vehicle Optimization Model is a powerful and objective tool, utilizing internal and external data sources, including guidebook residuals, Donlen’s National Auction Index for real-time resale performance, and U.S. Environmental Protection Agency performance statistics.

“We are color blind at Donlen. Our goal is to provide as much objective data to drive the right solutions that meet the individual customer needs,” said Dan Hannan, senior vice president of Strategic Consulting Services at Donlen.

While modeling costs is vital, other factors, such as environmental impact, are demanding higher degrees of attention. Through Donlen’s GreenKey environmental program, strategic consulting and FleetWeb provide tools to measure the impacts of vehicle selection and operation on the environment. As Brenda Davis, fleet commodity manager for Baker Hughes put it: “Understanding and communicating the impact of our fleet’s carbon output is a growing challenge, and Donlen’s GreenKey tools enabled me to provide information to senior leadership to serve as a baseline for coming years.”
 [PAGEBREAK] 

Measuring and Analyzing



Donlen Strategic Consulting Services’ Fleet Optimization Scorecard gives financial decision-makers actionable information by synthesizing all available data into a concise, easily digestible format. Donlen consultants meet with clients quarterly to review a comprehensive analysis of the major fleet cost centers, monitor behavior and performance, provide benchmarking, and identify and understand trends impacting fleet operations.

Ad Loading...

As Keith Smith, director of office and facility procurement for Houghton Mifflin Harcourt Publishing Co., explains, the right tools make all the difference.

“One of the main elements of information garnered through Donlen is the full page Overview of Fuel and Maintenance Expenses, which provides a detailed data and graphic view of quarter-to-quarter comparison for year-over-year realized expense,” said Smith. “I find the graph-oriented format of the data a key resource in our fleet decision making. Over a two-year period, this format will become the snapshot of the major driving forces associated with operating the fleet at a quick-glance reference.”

For Smith, that package is a roadmap to solutions that will be key for Houghton Mifflin Harcourt Co.’s continued success in operating its fleet.


Managing the Process

“Strategic consulting is not an event, but a living, breathing process,” said Hannan. A central element of Donlen Strategic Consulting Services is constant engagement and follow-up with customers. Donlen’s consultants meet with clients quarterly to formally review data and discuss trends and performance against peer benchmark groups and historical results. Together, consultants and customers work to uncover areas of opportunity, establish operational targets, and develop plans to drive change.

Ad Loading...

Kevin Wolf of Home Team Pest Defense said, “The consulting process provides me with a powerful tool that can be used within my own organization to communicate opportunities and progress. In addition, the data creates opportunities for me to apply benchmarks against my various branch locations to drive competitive behavior change.”

Currently, Donlen is also developing additional technology to add to its suite of proprietary tools. Donlen Corporation is based in Northbrook, Illinois.

Originally posted on Automotive Fleet

Subscribe to Our Newsletter

More Leasing

SponsoredMarch 1, 2026

Artificial Intelligence in Field Service: North America

48% of field service leaders are investing in AI to manage customer communication and self-service. Get the latest on how fleets are using AI and thinking about the future.

Read More →
Interior of a modern vehicle with digital dashboard graphics overlay and the words “Move Your Fleet Forward” beside the Merchants Fleet logo.
Leasingby News/Media ReleaseOctober 16, 2025

Merchants Fleet Evolves FleetShare

Merchants Fleet’s upgraded FleetShare platform boosts efficiency with keyless access, real-time data, telematics integration, and tools for smarter, scalable fleet management.

Read More →
Handshake in background with Partnerships and Element and Motus Logos.
Leasingby StaffAugust 5, 2025

Element and Motus Team Up to Offer Smarter Mobility Options for Fleets

The goal? Help companies optimize costs, simplify compliance, and support drivers, no matter what they’re driving.

Read More →
Ad Loading...
Graphic promoting the 2025 Fleet Management Company Research survey with a red checkmark and message “Input Needed!” for Work Truck and Automotive Fleet readers.
Leasingby Lauren FletcherJuly 20, 2025

Fleet Managers: It's Time to Evaluate Your FMC!

Help shape fleet services! Share your insights in the 2025 Fleet Management Company Research survey. Quick, anonymous, and impactful for fleets of all sizes.

Read More →
A collage of PacLease trucks, facilities, and staff interactions with a center banner that reads "45 Years PacLease Truck Rental and Leasing," celebrating the company’s 45th anniversary.
Leasingby News/Media ReleaseJuly 3, 2025

PacLease News: PacLease Celebrates 45th Anniversary

Paccar Leasing’s PacLease marks 45 years of full-service leasing operations, growing from 17 franchises to a global network supporting nearly 41,000 vehicles across five countries.

Read More →
Work Truck at the Show with Nick Delyani of Merchants Fleet
Leasingby Lauren FletcherApril 8, 2025

Merchants Fleet Talks Total Cost of Ownership and Tech Trends

How is Merchants Fleet using AI, data, and electrification to transform fleet management? Nick Delyani breaks it down.

Read More →
Ad Loading...
Matt Dyer Leadership Announcement Merchants Fleet
Leasingby News/Media ReleaseJanuary 28, 2025

Fleet Industry Veteran Matt Dyer Appointed as New CEO of Merchants Fleet

Merchants Fleet welcomes Matt Dyer as CEO, bringing decades of leadership expertise.

Read More →
Penske Solar Powered Facility
Leasingby StaffNovember 21, 2024

Penske Truck Leasing Lights Up New Solar-Powered Facility Initiative

Penske Truck Leasing powers up with solar! Discover how new rooftop systems at U.S. locations are driving sustainability, cutting costs, and reducing emissions.

Read More →
Leasingby News/Media ReleaseSeptember 25, 2024

Merchants Fleet Taps Ridecell to Streamline Short-Term Leasing

Merchants Fleet teams up with Ridecell to enhance fleet lifecycle management, enabling real-time vehicle tracking and data-driven decision-making.

Read More →
Ad Loading...
Holman showroom historical
Leasingby StaffAugust 22, 2024

Holman Marks 100 Years of 'Driving What's Right'

Holman celebrates 100 years of innovation in automotive services, from fleet management to vehicle upfitting, while staying true to its customer-first philosophy.

Read More →