Work Truck Logo
MenuMENU
SearchSEARCH

5 Differences Between Grandfathered AOBRDs and ELDs

Training on the operational differences between AOBRDs and ELDs is a critical component of the plan to help reduce the frustrations your drivers and operations department may experience on the first few days of your ELD launch.

Kathy Close
Kathy CloseCompliance Expert at J.J. Keller
Read Kathy's Posts
June 24, 2019
5 Differences Between Grandfathered AOBRDs and ELDs

An inspector shows a driver how to transfer his hours of service log at roadside – something that you have to be able to do with ELDs that you didn't with AOBRDs.

Photo courtesy CVSA

3 min to read


Motor carriers operating grandfathered automatic onboard recording devices (AOBRDs) to record their drivers’ hours of service must switch to an approved electronic logging device (ELD) by Dec. 16, 2019.

With little time remaining, carriers that want to minimize stress should plan to make the change sooner rather than later. Training on the operational differences between AOBRDs and ELDs is a critical component of the plan to help reduce the frustrations that your drivers and operations department may experience on the first few days of your ELD launch.

Ad Loading...

Some of the more significant differences include: 

1. Log-in Procedures 

When a driver logs into an ELD, he or she is prompted to accept or reject unassigned driving time on the device. Any accepted time is integrated into the driver’s records. Rejected time must be addressed by the back office by either assigning it to a specific driver or explaining through an attached comment why it could not be assigned.

AOBRDs, on the other hand, do not require annotation of the unassigned driving time when it cannot be attributed to a specific driver. The time could be attributed, instead, to a ghost account, which is not allowed with an ELD. 

2. Driving Status

AOBRDs allow the motor carrier to determine when an event is defined as driving (based on speed and distance traveled). But ELDs are more stringent and programmed to switch to the driving status when the vehicle reaches up to 5 mph unless the driver selects one of two categories: personal use or yard moves. 

Typically, when using these two categories while operating an AOBRD, drivers must log out of the device and then edit the time as on-duty, not driving.  

Ad Loading...

Fewer data entry errors equate to fewer roadside inspection violations, minimizing the effect on your company’s safety record. 

3. Editing Options

Unlike AOBRDs, an ELD system provides drivers with full editing rights, except for the automatic recording of all drive time. All other entries must be editable by the driver. Also, any edits made in the back office must be approved by the driver before becoming a part of his or her record.

Editing topics to reinforce with drivers include:

  • Acceptable/unacceptable edits,

  • How to make edits, and 

  • How to accept or reject back-office edits.

4. Data Transfer

During a roadside inspection, ELD log data is transferred directly to the officer. Drivers are expected to know the device’s transfer method (telematic or local transfer) and how to use the options within the method. The officer has the option of asking the driver to display or print the logs.

With AOBRDs, the driver is only required to show the officer the display. If the officer wants a copy of the records, the driver or carrier has up to 48 hours to provide them through any means.

Ad Loading...

In the event of a DOT audit, back-office personnel must be trained on this same ELD data transfer method. An investigator will expect a carrier to forward the ELD records using one of the transfer methods.

5. Generic Accounts

ELD systems do not allow for the use of generic or “ghost” accounts. Each account must have an actual person assigned to it, except for the unassigned driving time account. Driver accounts must include the driver’s license number to validate the driver. This means that carriers need to develop procedures for dealing with movements made by drivers without ELD accounts, sich as mechanics or supervisors. 

Create A Comfort Level Beforehand

Employees should be introduced to the equipment and its features before the day of conversion. This familiarity with your ELD will help reduce the number of entry errors. Fewer errors equate to fewer roadside inspection violations, minimizing the effect on your company’s safety record. 

Subscribe to Our Newsletter

More Safety

Illustration of a human hand reaching toward a robotic hand over an aerial view of a city at dusk, with interconnected location pins and network lines symbolizing AI, telematics, connected fleet technology, and data-driven transportation.
SafetyJuly 6, 2026

How Telematics Is Transforming Fleet Risk from Insight to Action

What if you could spot risky driving before it leads to a crash? See how telematics is still changing fleet safety today.

Read More →
View from inside a commercial truck cab showing a driver at the wheel with a large marijuana leaf overlaid by a red prohibition symbol, illustrating DOT restrictions on marijuana use for commercial drivers.
Safetyby Kathy CloseJuly 2, 2026

DOT Rules Remain Firmly Lit on Marijuana

DOT says not so fast on marijuana. Even with federal reclassification efforts, commercial drivers in safety-sensitive roles remain subject to marijuana testing and prohibitions.

Read More →
LytxOne promotional graphic featuring an in-cab dash camera and icons representing analytics, search, recording, video, reporting, driver performance, fuel, and location. Headline reads, “New Features Available Now.”
Safetyby News/Media ReleaseJuly 1, 2026

Lytx Adds Fleet Management Enhancements to LytxOne Platform

Lytx has added new features to LytxOne to bring safety, operational insight, asset visibility, and compliance into a unified, all-in-one platform.

Read More →
Ad Loading...
A shadowed figure removes cargo boxes from the back of a delivery van at night while fireworks explode in the background. Text overlay reads, "Before the Fireworks Start Review Your Cargo Security Plan."
Safetyby Lauren FletcherJune 23, 2026

A Fourth of July Cargo Theft Reality Check for Fleet Managers

The Fourth of July creates prime conditions for cargo theft. Here's what fleet managers should review now to protect loads, drivers and operations.

Read More →
Behind the Article thumbnail featuring Kathy Close of J.J. Keller. The image shows a road at sunset with bold text reading, “Do You Know What’s Driving Up Your CSA Score?” alongside Kathy Close discussing how fleets can use FMCSA's DataQs system to challenge inaccurate safety data and protect CSA scores.
Safetyby Lauren FletcherJune 19, 2026

What is DataQs and Why Should Fleets Care?

Watch to learn how FMCSA's DataQs system helps fleets challenge inaccurate safety data, protect CSA scores, and improve compliance records.

Read More →
Graphic featuring fireworks on a blue background with the headline "Stay Safe on the Road This July 4th" and the subheading "Tips From a Former Truck Driver." The image promotes road safety during holiday travel and accompanies advice on avoiding truck blind spots, passing safely, leaving adequate space around trucks, and planning travel during busy traffic periods.
Safetyby StaffJune 18, 2026

5 Safe Driving Tips for 4th of July

To ensure that this year’s fireworks remain in the sky and not on the roadway, follow these five easy steps to remain safe on the road this year – shared directly from a truck driver.

Read More →
Ad Loading...
Graphic for NSC National Safety Month featuring warehouse, trucking, and transportation workers. Text highlights safety priorities including moving safety forward, road safety, worker health, and preventing slips, trips, and falls.
Safetyby StaffJune 16, 2026

NSC Marks 30 Years of National Safety Month, Includes Road Safety Focus

The Staying Safe on the Roads topic is one of four weekly focuses in June as the National Safety Council observes the 30th anniversary of National Safety Month. NSC also provides insights on the need for fleets to create a safety policy.

Read More →
Person using a laptop to view a fleet management dashboard displaying weather alerts, vehicle speed data, maps, and road-condition images. The screen highlights a snowy roadway and a lake-effect snow warning for a fleet vehicle.
Safetyby News/Media ReleaseJune 12, 2026

Fleetworthy Integrates Lytx Video Snapshots to Improve Driver Coaching

Fleetworthy’s integration of Lytx video snapshots enables fleet managers to combine visual event evidence with Safety+ risk data, helping them make faster, more informed coaching decisions without leaving the Fleetworthy platform.

Read More →
Graphic showing the word “RECALL” painted in large yellow letters across a road surface with double yellow center lines. “June” appears at top left, and the Work Truck logo appears at bottom right.
Safetyby Wayne ParhamJune 10, 2026

Recalls You Need to Know About in June 2026

In June 2026, what recalls might impact your fleet? Work Truck has the answers in this comprehensive overview of recent NHTSA recalls.

Read More →
Ad Loading...
J. J. Keller & Associates, Inc. Safety Professional of the Year award logo, featuring the company name, stylized “K” emblem, and bold “SPOTY” acronym above the title “Safety Professional of the Year.”
Safetyby News/Media ReleaseJune 8, 2026

J. J. Keller Safety Professional of the Year Awards Nominations Now Open

J. J. Keller & Associates is accepting nominations for the 2026 J. J. Keller Safety Professional of the Year (SPOTY) Awards. Winners will receive prize packages valued at up to $47,200.

Read More →