Edmunds.com Evaluates Payback Period of Hybrid and Diesel Vehicles
"As a general rule, we found that diesels are more affordable than hybrids, taking into account the vehicles' prices, tax credits and fuel usage," notes Edmunds' AutoObserver.com Senior Editor Bill Visnic.
Fluctuating gas prices, expiring tax credits and economic instability have many consumers wondering if purchasing a hybrid or diesel vehicle is the most cost-effective choice in today's market. An updated study by Edmunds.com compares the payback period of the newest hybrid and diesel vehicles compared to their gasoline vehicle counterparts.
"As a general rule, we found that diesels are more affordable than hybrids, taking into account the vehicles' prices, tax credits and fuel usage," notes Edmunds' AutoObserver.com Senior Editor Bill Visnic, who participated in the panel "The Green Car of the Future" with representatives from BMW, Toyota and The New York Times, this evening at the Japan Society in New York.
Set forth below are the annual gas savings and payback periods for the latest hybrid and diesel models as compared to their gasoline-driven counterparts:
Sample Hybrid Comparisons:
Year | Make | Model | Federal Tax Credit | True Market Value | Hybrid Premium | Annual Hybrid Gas Savings | Years to Break Even |
2010 | BMW | 7 Series | $82,613 | ||||
2010 | BMW | Active Hybrid 7 | $0 | $103,175 | $20,562 | $362 | 56.8 |
2010 | Cadillac | Escalade | $66,992 | ||||
2010 | Cadillac | Escalade Hybrid | $2,200 | $67,140 | $148 | $801 | 0.2 |
2010 | Chevrolet | Tahoe | $43,160 | ||||
2010 | Chevrolet | Tahoe Hybrid | $2,200 | $47,626 | $4,466 | $483 | 9.3 |
2010 | Ford | Escape | $23,608 | ||||
2010 | Ford | Escape Hybrid | $750 | $28,261 | $4,653 | $543 | 8.6 |
2010 | Ford | Fusion | $21,484 | ||||
2010 | Ford | Fusion Hybrid | $850 | $26,229 | $4,745 | $573 | 8.3 |
2010 | GMC | Sierra | $32,753 | ||||
2010 | GMC | Sierra Hybrid | $2,200 | $35,792 | $3,039 | $442 | 6.9 |
2010 | GMC | Yukon | $44,883 | ||||
2010 | GMC | Yukon Hybrid | $2,200 | $48,320 | $3,437 | $483 | 7.1 |
2010 | Honda | Civic | $19,245 | ||||
2010 | Honda | Civic Hybrid | $0 | $22,526 | $3,281 | $453 | 7.2 |
2010 | Honda | Civic | $17,489 | ||||
2010 | Honda | Insight | $0 | $19,222 | $1,733 | $434 | 4.0 |
2010 | Lexus | ES 350 | $33,702 | ||||
2010 | Lexus | HS 250h | $0 | $33,336 | -$366 | $894 | -0.4 |
2010 | Lexus | LS 460 | $70,763 | ||||
2010 | Lexus | LS 600h L | $0 | $100,603 | $29,840 | $277 | 107.6 |
2010 | Lexus | RX 350 | $35,913 | ||||
2010 | Lexus | RX 450h | $0 | $40,855 | $4,942 | $709 | 7.0 |
2010 | Mercedes-Benz | S-Class | $89,254 | ||||
2010 | Mercedes-Benz | S-Class Hybrid | $1,150 | $84,592 | -$4,662 | $462- | 10.1 |
2010 | Mercury | Mariner | $23,302 | ||||
2010 | Mercury | Mariner Hybrid | $750 | $28,652 | $5,350 | $437 | 12.2 |
2010 | Mercury | Milan | $24,346 | ||||
2010 | Mercury | Milan Hybrid | $850 | $26,417 | $2,071 | $573 | 3.6 |
2010 | Nissan | Altima | $21,476 | ||||
2010 | Nissan | Altima Hybrid | $2,350 | $23,824 | $2,348 | $364 | 6.5 |
2010 | Toyota | Camry | $24,499 | ||||
2010 | Toyota | Camry Hybrid | $0 | $25,014 | $515 | $386 | 1.3 |
2010 | Toyota | Camry | $20,924 | ||||
2010 | Toyota | Prius | $0 | $22,918 | $1,994 | $797 | 2.5 |
2010 | Toyota | Highlander | $27,665 | ||||
2010 | Toyota | Highlander Hybrid | $0 | $33,244 | $5,579 | $571 | 9.8 |
Sample Diesel Comparisons:
Year | Make | Model | Tax Credit | Final TMV | Diesel Premium | Annual Gas Cost | Years to Break Even |
2010 | Audi | A3 | $0 | $28,413 | $1,731 | ||
2010 | Audi | A3 | $1,300 | $28,250 | -$163 | $1,285 | -0.4 |
2010 | Audi | Q7 | $0 | $46,296 | $2,654 | ||
2010 | Audi | Q7 | $1,150 | $49,266 | $2,970 | $2,228 | 7.0 |
2010 | BMW | 3 Series | $0 | $39,209 | $2,093 | ||
2010 | BMW | 3 Series | $900 | $41,740 | $2,531 | $1,611 | 5.3 |
2010 | BMW | X5 | $0 | $46,475 | $2,449 | ||
2010 | BMW | X5 | $1,800 | $48,229 | $1,754 | $2,047 | 4.4 |
2010 | Mercedes-Benz | GL-Class | $0 | $59,237 | $2,899 | ||
2010 | Mercedes-Benz | GL-Class | $1,800 | $56,485 | -$2,752 | $2,297 | -4.6 |
2010 | Mercedes-Benz | M-Class | $0 | $47,023 | $2,494 | ||
2010 | Mercedes-Benz | M-Class | $900 | $47,565 | $542 | $2,149 | 1.6 |
2010 | Mercedes-Benz | R-Class | $0 | $48,092 | $2,654 | ||
2010 | Mercedes-Benz | R-Class | $1,550 | $47,986 | -$106 | $2,182 | -0.2 |
2010 | Volkswagen | Golf | $0 | $20,979 | $1,804 | ||
2010 | Volkswagen | Golf | $1,700 | $22,910 | $1,931 | $1,285 | 3.7 |
2010 | Volkswagen | Jetta | $0 | $21,632 | $1,804 | ||
2010 | Volkswagen | Jetta | $1,300 | $22,852 | $1,220 | $1,285 | 2.4 |
2010 | Volkswagen | Touareg | $0 | $39,358 | $2,654 | ||
2010 | Volkswagen | Touareg | $1,150 | $41,494 | $2,136 | $2,149 | 4.2 |
This study assumed the vehicles were sold at the Edmunds.com True Market Value price, were driven 15,000 miles per year and achieved the Environmental Protection Agency's recorded mileage for combined city and highway driving. Average gas prices were assumed to be $3.09 per gallon of premium unleaded, $2.81 per gallon of regular unleaded and $2.95 per gallon of diesel.
The federal tax credit and current incentives were applied when appropriate. Please note that Ford and Mercury hybrid vehicle tax credits will be eliminated on April 1, 2010, but consumers who order one before March 31 qualify for the credit. Tax credits for Honda and Toyota hybrids have already been phased out.
More Small Fleet
Why Fleet Managers Are Replacing Departmental Vehicles with Shared Motor Pools
Departmentally assigned vehicles often create hidden costs through underutilization, poor visibility, and increased administrative burden. This white paper explores how shared motor pool strategies help fleets reduce costs, improve accountability, and optimize vehicle utilization.
Read More →
Boosting Last-Mile Fleet Uptime, Safety, and Value with AI Vehicle Inspections
AI-powered inspections are transforming last-mile fleets by replacing manual checks with highly accurate automated scans that detect defects in seconds. By giving fleet operations visibility into the daily condition of their vehicles, you can identify trends over the vehicle’s lifecycle that enable improved procurement decisions, route management, driver training and accountability.
Read More →
Five Ways Seat Belts Help Prevent Injuries
There are five ways seat belts protect occupants from injuries, according to the Tennessee Department of Safety and Homeland Security.
Read More →
It’s here: The 2026 Fleet Technology Trends Report
What does AI mean for fleets? Get the answer — and learn other top tech trends.
Read More →
Small Fleets, Big Impact: How Independent Drivers Power Wreaths Across America
Check out how small fleets and independent drivers power Wreaths Across America each December and why their impact matters more than ever.
Read More →
VMS Survey Finds 65% of Small Fleet Managers Run Operations Alone
A new VMS survey shows small fleet managers are stretched thin, with most handling operations solo and eager to adopt digital tools for relief.
Read More →
Tips for Driving Safely on Halloween Night
This video features a reminder from the Connecticut Department of Transportation (DOT) and the Connecticut Police Chiefs Association, urging drivers to prioritize safety this Halloween.
Read More →
AI, Access, and Uptime: VMS’s Next Chapter with David Prusinski
VMS’s new Co-CEO, David Prusinski, shares how an AI-first approach will give small fleets and repair shops the tools to compete like big players.
Read More →
Fleet Managers Share Winter Prep Tips: It's Never Too Early!
Three fleets share best practices to prep vehicles for winter and prevent downtime when the cold sets in.
Read More →
Hot Weather Driving Tips for Fleet Drivers
As we head into another potentially extreme summer season, the risks for fleet drivers remain high, from engine strain and tire blowouts to unpredictable traffic patterns. An expert shares advice on how fleet drivers can boost their safety during the steamy summer months.
Read More →