Work Truck Logo
MenuMENU
SearchSEARCH

Why 3 in 10 Fleets Aren't ELD Compliant

Up to three in 10 fleets are not yet compliant with the electronic logging device (ELD) mandate. Some of the top barriers are discussed with tips on how to overcome them.

by Adam Bruttell, MiX Telematics
December 18, 2018
Why 3 in 10 Fleets Aren't ELD Compliant

Don’t let concerns about implementations and driver acceptance and training paralyze you into not taking action. The ELD Mandate is not going away – take action now to protect your business.

Photo courtesy of MiX Telematics

4 min to read


The electronic logging device (ELD) Mandate went into effect in December 2017, but a spring 2018 MiX Telematics survey found that 3 in 10 fleets (29%) that were subject to the Mandate were still not compliant. 

Ad Loading...

Some of those fleets had been grandfathered in with automatic onboard recording devices (AOBRDs) – 13% had plans to implement ELDs by December 2019. But the balance hadn’t started the process, were still evaluating solutions, had implemented something but needed to replace it, or just weren’t sure if they were compliant yet.

Ad Loading...

While the vernacular of e-Log technology has changed a lot over time (e-logs, OBC, AOBRD, ELD, etc.), the general premise has not – moving from paper logs to electronic logs improves safety and efficiency. In my experience, there are two main barriers for fleets moving to e-logs: the hassle of installing the hardware and software, and driver acceptance and training. Both are relatively easy to overcome if you have the right information and help.

Hardware & Software Installation

Fleets rarely have to do this on their own (only very low-end ELD systems require self installation), and because it can be done in stages, it doesn’t require a complete shutdown of your fleet. Some fleets implement by region, others by vehicle type. As with any big IT upgrade, often the software can be implemented off hours, such as a weekend or overnight. Most fleets run a small pilot to ensure everything’s working correctly before committing to a broad rollout.

Integrating your new ELD software with legacy software is one area to pay close attention to. If your ELD vendor has prebuilt integrations (APIs) with your legacy software, you’ll reduce the potential for problems substantially. Custom integrations introduce risk.

Another feature to look for to ease software implementation: the ability to perform over-the-air updates. ELD requirements change often at the state and federal level – you will likely find yourself having to roll out important updates at least once a quarter. The ability to do those over the air will save your team a ton of time, and keep your vehicles on the road, in service.

Driver Acceptance & Training

Often, drivers resist ELDs. That’s because many fleets position them as a tool for managers rather than for drivers. Truth is, the top objective for the vast majority of ELD implementations (beyond the obvious compliance requirement) is to ensure driver safety. 

Ad Loading...

The best way to get driver buy-in for your ELD rollout is to emphasize this fact early and often: driver safety is the top priority. Start communicating with drivers long before the rollout, and make them a part of the process. Engage drivers in planning workflows, have them participate in pilots, and solicit their input when designing incentive programs for safe driving.

I know of fleets whose drivers first heard about the new ELD program when they were handed the telematics policy for review and signature. Don’t be that fleet.

Training should also be collaborative. Ben Sigmund, former Director of Operational Logistics at C&J Energy (who led his company’s ELD rollout), said that in-person training was far more effective with drivers than web-based training or conference calls. C&J also created an intranet site with all the training and support materials, including printable cab cards for drivers to use as they familiarized themselves with the software.

Lean on your vendor to help you with this process, since they’ve likely done it hundreds of times and already know what works best.

Grandfathered in with AOBRDs?

If you are grandfathered in with AOBRDs, you should start your migration by the first quarter of 2019 to be done in time.

Ad Loading...

As 2017 came to a close, with the ELD Mandate deadline imminent, many inquiries came in from fleets that were not grandfathered in, and had only a few months or weeks to get a new system in place. Unfortunately, most of those fleets missed the deadline (or implemented something quickly, which they now regret – the aforementioned survey found that 3% of fleets were in this boat, having to replace what they implemented).

Evaluating, selecting and implementing an ELD solution is a multi-month process. Having been through it many times now, I recommend that fleets start a year in advance, as the implementation alone can take about six months. Fleets that start in January 2019 will likely be finished by July 2019, giving them a few months to work out any kinks before their compliance deadline.

Fleets that aren’t ELD compliant, with either an AOBRD or ELD solution, are taking a huge risk. The FMCSA is actively enforcing the regulation, levying fines and even taking vehicles out of service. We’ve heard of numerous fleets that thought they were exempt under state laws (this seems common in Texas), but then learned they can no longer cross state lines.

Don’t let concerns about implementations and driver acceptance and training paralyze you into not taking action. The ELD Mandate is not going away – take action now to protect your business.

And, while fleets made progress in 2018 - MiX estimates that by now only 2 in 10 fleets are not ELD compliant. But that number should be zero. These barriers are likely what's holding them back.

Ad Loading...

About the Author: Adam Bruttell is the Vice President, North America of MiX Telematics. 

Subscribe to Our Newsletter

More Technology & AI

Truck Chat thumbnail featuring Lauren Fletcher beside the headline “What’s Costing Your Fleet Time?” Topics include downtime, theft, storm planning, and electric trucks. Sponsored by Chevron.
Sponsored•by Lauren Fletcher•October 29, 2026

Fleet Downtime, Truck Theft, and Electric Growth Lead This Month

Where is your fleet losing time? This Truck Chat recap connects repair delays, theft risks, storm planning, and lessons from scaling electric trucks.

Read More →
HCSS Fleet and Verizon Connect logos displayed over images of heavy construction equipment, including Caterpillar excavators and articulated dump trucks operating at a rocky construction site.
Technology & AI•by News/Media Release•October 26, 2026

HCSS Partners with Verizon Connect to Deliver Fleet Intelligence for Construction Fleets

HCSS has integrated with Verizon Connect to provide near real-time fleet insights so contractors can spend less time tracking assets and more time keeping projects on schedule.

Read More →
Work Truck Trucks, Tips & Tours YouTube thumbnail featuring a WEX representative discussing fuel fraud prevention, with the headline “Stop Fuel Fraud With AI & Telematics,” WEX backdrop, and Truck Chat Watch Now button.
Technology & AI•by Wayne Parham•October 20, 2026

How Fleets Can Use Technology to Fight Fuel Fraud

Fuel fraud and theft remain significant challenges for commercial fleets, whether the problem involves third-party fraud or driver misuse. In this video, David Abraham of WEX explains how SecureFuel uses vehicle geolocation, telematics, transaction information, and AI to help fleet managers identify suspicious fuel purchases and make more informed decisions.

Read More →
Ad Loading...
A speaker stands at an American Trucking Associations podium during a conference presentation, with a large Motive logo displayed on the screen behind him.
Technology & AI•by Lauren Fletcher•October 20, 2026

Can AI Agents Help Small Work Truck Fleets Do More With Less?

Motive's new AI Agents automate fleet safety, maintenance, compliance, and dispatch tasks. Here's how they work for smaller fleets, what managers control, and what early users are seeing.

Read More →
Interior view of a Kenworth commercial truck cab featuring a multifunction steering wheel, digital instrument cluster, touchscreen infotainment system, dashboard controls, and PACCAR Connect branding in the lower right corner.
Technology & AI•by News/Media Release•October 19, 2026

Paccar Launches Paccar Connect for Peterbilt and Kenworth Trucks

The new Paccar Connect offers touchscreen displays, telematics capabilities, and an expanding app ecosystem to boost productivity and streamline driver workflows.

Read More →
White ISEE autonomous yard truck parked in a shipping yard surrounded by freight trailers and containers.
Technology & AI•by News/Media Release•October 12, 2026

Holman and ISEE Partner to Expand Autonomous Yard Truck Operations

The partnership combines Holman's fleet management and upfitting capabilities with ISEE's autonomous driving technology to help businesses deploy and manage driverless yard trucks.

Read More →
Ad Loading...
White Rivian R1S SUV customized as the Ghostbusters Ecto-R1, featuring the Ghostbusters logo, red accents, roof-mounted equipment, and emergency-style lights.
Technology & AI•October 12, 2026

Who You Gonna Call? Rivian Turns Electric Vehicles Into Ghostbusters Rides

Rivian teams up with Sony Pictures for a Ghostbusters-inspired Halloween software update, complete with custom sounds, lighting effects, and a special Ecto-R1.

Read More →
Graphic reading “Taking Second Trips?” over a blue map with a route line and location pin.
Technology & AI•October 8, 2026

The Second Trip and What Missing Tools Really Cost a Service Business

For service fleets, missing tools and equipment can lead to second trips, lost technician time, higher operating costs, and delayed jobs. Equipment tracking can help HVAC, plumbing, electrical, landscaping, and other service businesses improve visibility and reduce downtime.

Read More →
Illustrated map showing a blue circular geofence boundary around a defined geographic area.
Technology & AI•by Staff•October 6, 2026

GeoFencing Adds to Your Truck Security Arsenal

Geofencing is a familiar fleet tool today, but its early adoption marked a major shift in vehicle tracking, route monitoring, and the debate over employee privacy.

Read More →
Ad Loading...
Supply chain graphic showing a cargo port, container ship, warehouse, and semi-trucks beneath a global logistics network map with the words “State of the Supply Chain.”
Technology & AI•by Lauren Fletcher•September 22, 2026

Geotab Data Shows Regional Trucking Growing Faster as Last Mile Routes Get Denser

Geotab's first U.S. supply chain report finds stable long-haul activity, stronger regional freight movement, tighter hub-and-spoke utilization, and more last-mile trips on shorter routes.

Read More →