Highway Bill Patch Could Derail Over Train Safety Measure
The latest proposed extension of federal highway funding includes a provision to delay a mandate for automatic-braking equipment on trains that could turn passing the measure into a game of political football.

NTSB investigators at scene of Amtrak derailment in Philadelphia on May 12 that killed eight passengers and injured another 200. Photo: NTSB

NTSB investigators at scene of Amtrak derailment in Philadelphia on May 12 that killed eight passengers and injured another 200. Photo: NTSB
The latest extension of federal highway funding will last all of 22 days. Just introduced in the House, the Surface Transportation Extension Act of 2015 (H.R. 3819) would fund and extend the authorization for federal highway and transit programs through November 20.
The good news is this latest funding patch can be voted on by Congress with no need for additional funds to be approved, as the Highway Trust Fund will remain solvent through the period it seeks to cover.
The bad news is this patch includes a provision to delay a mandate calling for automatic-braking equipment on trains that could turn passing the measure into a game of political football.
H.R. 3819 was introduced by Transportation and Infrastructure Committee Chairman Rep. Bill Shuster (R-PA), T&I Ranking Member Peter DeFazio (D-OR) and Ways and Means Committee Chairman Paul Ryan (R-WI).
“This extension will allow the highway bill process to continue moving forward without shutting down transportation programs and projects across the country,” Shuster said in an Oct. 26 statement.
“Last week, the Transportation Committee unanimously approved the bipartisan, multi-year Surface Transportation Reauthorization and Reform Act of 2015,” Shuster noted. “We look forward to voting on that bill in the House soon and then going to conference with the Senate on their highway bill. I am confident that we can resolve the differences between the House and Senate measures and producing a final product that’s good for our nation’s infrastructure.”
But there's more. “This legislation also includes a necessary, bipartisan extension of the deadline for implementation of Positive Train Control technology,” Shuster stated. “We need to extend the Positive Train Control deadline as soon as possible to prevent significant disruptions of both passenger and freight rail service across the country.”
Intense lobbying by the railroad industry is credited with getting the T&I Committee to approve extending the deadline to install PTC automatic braking on roughly 70,000 miles of track from the end of this year until 2018.
That effort succeeded despite the push by safety advocates for PTC to be implemented on time that picked up speed back on May 12, when the crash of an Amtrak train that derailed in Philadelphia killed eight passengers and injured another 200.
Shuster contended in his statement that “freight railroads have indicated they will suspend shipments of certain chemicals, such as chlorine used to purify drinking water and anhydrous ammonia used in fertilizer, well before the end of the year” if the PTC deadline is not extended.
He added that “some freight railroads may suspend all shipments of commodities. Passenger rail service will also be impacted: commuter railroads will have to suspend operations, and Amtrak service outside of the corridor between Washington and New York will stop.”
The problem is not everyone in Congress has bought the railroads’ argument. As reported by Politico transportation reporter Heather Caygle, “congressional infighting over PTC has threatened to derail the plan” especially because a key player, Sen. Barbara Boxer (D-CA), is committed to blocking any highway bill that kicks the PTC can as far down the tracks as this latest patch would.
Boxer is the Ranking Member of the Senate Environment & Public Works Committee, which must approve any highway bill passed by the House before sending it to the full Senate for consideration.
PTC uses electronic technology to prevent train-to-train collisions, over-speed derailments, incursions into work zones and the movement of a train through a main line switch that is improperly set. The Rail Safety Improvement Act of 2008 (RSIA) mandates that PTC be implemented across a significant portion of the nation's tracks by December 31, 2015.
Per the Federal Railroad Administration, PTC will be required on “essentially Class I railroad main lines (i.e., over which 5 million or more gross tons are transported annually) that handle any poisonous-inhalation-hazardous (PIH) materials; and, any railroad main lines over which regularly scheduled intercity passenger or commuter rail services are provided.”
Originally posted on Automotive Fleet
More Operations

Where’s My Truck: Inside the Fleet Logistics Work Nobody Sees
Shades of Fleet video thumbnail featuring Lauren Fletcher beside the text “The People Behind the Process, Keeping Fleets Moving,” with fleet vehicles and logistics imagery in the background.
Read More →
Work Truck Seeks Fleet and Industry Insights on 2026 Trends and 2027 Forecasts
Work Truck is seeking insights from fleet leaders and industry partners on the trends that shaped 2026 and what commercial fleets should prepare for in 2027. Participate today!
Read More →
It's 10 p.m... Do You Know Who Has Access to Your Fleet?
Preventing cargo theft requires investment in technology, operational processes, and employee training. In an industry with tight margins, it can be difficult to justify investments whose value is measured by incidents that might never occur.
Read More →From Our Partners
Basic Tracking vs Next Generation Fleet Technology
Sponsored by AT&T Business

5 Facts Every Fleet Manager Should Know About Embedded Telematics
Sponsored by Stellantis/Mobilisights

How AI Video Telematics Boosts Driver Safety and Helps to Avoid Unnecessary Costs
Sponsored by Verizon Connect

Charting the 8 Bottom-Line Benefits of Workforce Optimization
Sponsored by Verizon Connect


GeoFencing Adds to Your Truck Security Arsenal
Geofencing is a familiar fleet tool today, but its early adoption marked a major shift in vehicle tracking, route monitoring, and the debate over employee privacy.
Read More →
Truckers’ Strike Rumors, New GM Engines, and Hidden Idling Costs Lead This Week’s News
Truckers’ strike rumors, GM’s new 2027 engines, hidden idling costs, racing lessons, IRP rules, and more headline this week’s Truck Chat Weekly Cheat Sheet.
Read More →
Shades of Fleet Wants to Hear From You About Building a Culture of Care
Fleet leaders, we want to hear from you. Share how empathy, trust, and creating space for people can strengthen your team, improve performance, and support retention.
Read More →
What Racing Can Teach Work Truck Fleets About the Work Nobody Sees
Race car driver and mechanical engineer Isaac Johnson shares practical lessons on preparation, relationships, setbacks, and building teams that perform when it counts.
Read More →
New Fleet Guides, Hidden Truck Wear, and Driver Fit Lead This Month
Our latest Truck Chat recap covers new Fleet Guides, hidden idling costs, driver fit, lighter-truck registration rules, and year-round technician appreciation.
Read More →
Work Truck Takes Fleet Rivalry Downhill to Support Skilled Trades
Team Fletcher claimed a head-to-head win and second overall as Work Truck and Automotive Fleet helped raise $22,000 for the Hourglass Foundation.
Read More →From Ledger Books to AI Patti Earley Shares 40 Years of Fleet Lessons
Patti Earley, CAFM, shares what four decades in fleet have taught her about using data, building relationships, and listening to the people behind the vehicles.
Read More →
