CA Considers Insurance That Charges Based on Miles Driven
Supporters say the legislation protects the environment and eases congestion. Opponents worry about privacy and say it punishes drivers in rural areas.
Auto insurance companies would charge customers based on the number of miles actually driven, under legislation being considered in California. The plan is designed to cut motoring costs, protect the environment and reduce traffic congestion, according to the Los Angeles Times.
An alliance of insurance companies and environmentalists is touting “pay as you drive” insurance. The option is available from a few insurers in 34 states -- but not California -- as well as Canada, Japan and Europe.
One company, GMAC Insurance Group, says its customers have reduced the premiums they pay by 13 percent to 54 percent. Customers’ mileage is tracked by General Motors Corp.’s OnStar system.
Opponents, mainly privacy advocates, say they fear that insurance companies could begin tracking more than just a driver’s mileage. Privacy advocates worry that companies might install sophisticated GPS devices on cars that would communicate via satellite where and when motorists travel and whether they are speeding or driving recklessly.
One Orlando, Fla. man said he cut his insurance bill by $634 a year for his Cadillac Escalade and his Saab convertible by switching to a GMAC pay-as-you-drive policy.
A study by the Brookings Institution, a Washington think tank, says pay as you drive could create $52 billion in annual benefits from fewer accidents, reduced traffic and pollution, and less reliance on foreign oil.
California Assemblyman Jared Huffman, the author of the California legislation to authorize pay as you drive in California, said the bill rewards people who drive less. Opponents in the legislature say the measure punishes people who live in rural areas. But Huffman's measure is sailing through the legislature with little opposition.
Proponents, including trade groups representing most major insurance companies, say that with gasoline prices near $5 a gallon and likely to head higher, now is the perfect time for pay as you drive.
Huffman’s measure would allow the tracking of mileage but didn’t endorse GPS surveillance. His bill would leave details about how to record mileage to the California Department of Insurance.
State Insurance Commissioner Steve Poizner said he intended to explore techniques that are less invasive than GPS. Those include using electronic monitors that check only odometer readings, accessing maintenance records and authorizing smog inspection stations to report mileage readings.
But one California resident, Yves Didier, was quoted in the Los Angeles Times as saying driving less should be strictly voluntary.
"I personally would not want a device in my vehicle. I feel like it’s another step toward Big Brother watching me," he said.
More Small Fleet

Why Fleet Managers Are Replacing Departmental Vehicles with Shared Motor Pools
Departmentally assigned vehicles often create hidden costs through underutilization, poor visibility, and increased administrative burden. This white paper explores how shared motor pool strategies help fleets reduce costs, improve accountability, and optimize vehicle utilization.
Read More →
Boosting Last-Mile Fleet Uptime, Safety, and Value with AI Vehicle Inspections
AI-powered inspections are transforming last-mile fleets by replacing manual checks with highly accurate automated scans that detect defects in seconds. By giving fleet operations visibility into the daily condition of their vehicles, you can identify trends over the vehicle’s lifecycle that enable improved procurement decisions, route management, driver training and accountability.
Read More →
Five Ways Seat Belts Help Prevent Injuries
There are five ways seat belts protect occupants from injuries, according to the Tennessee Department of Safety and Homeland Security.
Read More →
It’s here: The 2026 Fleet Technology Trends Report
What does AI mean for fleets? Get the answer — and learn other top tech trends.
Read More →
Small Fleets, Big Impact: How Independent Drivers Power Wreaths Across America
Check out how small fleets and independent drivers power Wreaths Across America each December and why their impact matters more than ever.
Read More →
VMS Survey Finds 65% of Small Fleet Managers Run Operations Alone
A new VMS survey shows small fleet managers are stretched thin, with most handling operations solo and eager to adopt digital tools for relief.
Read More →
Tips for Driving Safely on Halloween Night
This video features a reminder from the Connecticut Department of Transportation (DOT) and the Connecticut Police Chiefs Association, urging drivers to prioritize safety this Halloween.
Read More →
AI, Access, and Uptime: VMS’s Next Chapter with David Prusinski
VMS’s new Co-CEO, David Prusinski, shares how an AI-first approach will give small fleets and repair shops the tools to compete like big players.
Read More →
Fleet Managers Share Winter Prep Tips: It's Never Too Early!
Three fleets share best practices to prep vehicles for winter and prevent downtime when the cold sets in.
Read More →
Hot Weather Driving Tips for Fleet Drivers
As we head into another potentially extreme summer season, the risks for fleet drivers remain high, from engine strain and tire blowouts to unpredictable traffic patterns. An expert shares advice on how fleet drivers can boost their safety during the steamy summer months.
Read More →
