Work Truck Logo
MenuMENU
SearchSEARCH

Automakers, Dealers Push to Revoke N.Y.’s Vicarious Liability Law

by Staff
May 14, 2004
3 min to read


For New York residents, obtaining leased vehicles are becoming increasingly more difficult due to the state’s vicarious liability laws. To date, every major retail bank along with 19 automakers have opted out of vehicle leasing in the state. Vicarious liability laws (a state law) emerged in the 1800s as a way to hold carriage owners at fault for accidents, whether or not they were operating the vehicle. Livery drivers and chauffeurs, penniless in comparison to their employ-ers, could not afford to pay for personal injury or property damages they may have caused, letting the responsibility pass onto vehicle owners. Today, that owner is legally defined as the person or business whose name ap-pears on the vehicle title. In the case of leased vehicles, the owner would be the financial institution providing the lease. This poses a problem for the auto industry because leasing companies have no control over the day-to-day activities of the indi-viduals driving their vehicles. Forty-nine states have recognized this dilemma and have adjusted their respective state regulations to limit the amount of liability for damages caused by negligent drivers. New York is the only state where courts and legislatures have imposed vi-carious liability on companies solely be-cause their names appear on a vehicle’s title, which leaves them greatly exposed to multi-million dollar lawsuits and claims. For consumers, this means less choice and higher payments in a state where 25 percent of new vehicles are leased, reach-ing up to 80 percent at some high-end and metropolitan area dealers. In May, the Alliance of Automobile Manufacturers and the Greater New York Automobile Dealers Association released information stating that consumers are paying an additional $130 million a year in sales taxes and acquisition fees. Also, be-cause of the antiquated law, new car and light truck leasing declined by 36 percent in the state, twice the national average. Mid-size pickups saw a reduction of 89 percent. Although the unavailability of leases is costing some dealers business, several automakers that no longer lease vehicles have begun to offer “balloon” loans as alternatives. Like leases, these loans feature lower monthly payments and, at the end of the contract, consumers can either make a large final payment or return the vehicle altogether. These payments tend to be higher than leases, however, because sales tax is paid on the entire vehicle value rather than just a portion. On the legislative end, A.1042, a bill sponsored by Assemblyman Ronald Canestrari (D-Albany), would declare the driver of a leased vehicle to be the owner in any lease of more than one year. Two others, one by State Senator Own Johnson (R-West Babylon), would limit liability to $300,000 per accident or repeal vicarious liability for leasing purposes. All are pend-ing in the State Assembly.

More Small Fleet

Cover of a whitepaper titled “The Hidden Costs of Departmentally Assigned Vehicles on Your Fleet” featuring a black fleet vehicle driving on a road at sunset. Subheadline reads: “Discover how your fleet can reduce costs and minimize risk by implementing vehicle sharing.” The document focuses on fleet optimization, vehicle sharing, cost reduction, utilization tracking, and risk management for fleet operations.
SponsoredMay 13, 2026

Why Fleet Managers Are Replacing Departmental Vehicles with Shared Motor Pools

Departmentally assigned vehicles often create hidden costs through underutilization, poor visibility, and increased administrative burden. This white paper explores how shared motor pool strategies help fleets reduce costs, improve accountability, and optimize vehicle utilization.

Read More →
SponsoredMarch 9, 2026

Boosting Last-Mile Fleet Uptime, Safety, and Value with AI Vehicle Inspections

AI-powered inspections are transforming last-mile fleets by replacing manual checks with highly accurate automated scans that detect defects in seconds. By giving fleet operations visibility into the daily condition of their vehicles, you can identify trends over the vehicle’s lifecycle that enable improved procurement decisions, route management, driver training and accountability.

Read More →
SafetyFebruary 4, 2026

Five Ways Seat Belts Help Prevent Injuries

There are five ways seat belts protect occupants from injuries, according to the Tennessee Department of Safety and Homeland Security.

Read More →
Ad Loading...
SponsoredJanuary 14, 2026

It’s here: The 2026 Fleet Technology Trends Report

What does AI mean for fleets? Get the answer — and learn other top tech trends.

Read More →
Wreaths Across America graphic highlighting the role of small fleets in delivering wreaths to honor veterans, featuring wreath icons and the American flag.
Small Fleetby Lauren FletcherDecember 8, 2025

Small Fleets, Big Impact: How Independent Drivers Power Wreaths Across America

Check out how small fleets and independent drivers power Wreaths Across America each December and why their impact matters more than ever.

Read More →
A stressed person covers their face, illustrating that 65% of small fleet managers handle all operations alone, according to a Vehicle Management Systems (VMS) survey.
Small Fleetby StaffNovember 12, 2025

VMS Survey Finds 65% of Small Fleet Managers Run Operations Alone

A new VMS survey shows small fleet managers are stretched thin, with most handling operations solo and eager to adopt digital tools for relief.

Read More →
Ad Loading...
Safe Driving on Halloween over spooky fall road
Safetyby StaffOctober 20, 2025

Tips for Driving Safely on Halloween Night

This video features a reminder from the Connecticut Department of Transportation (DOT) and the Connecticut Police Chiefs Association, urging drivers to prioritize safety this Halloween.

Read More →
VMS Co-CEO David Prusinski highlights the company’s AI-powered virtual fleet manager designed to improve uptime and reduce operating costs for fleets.
Green Fleetby Lauren FletcherOctober 6, 2025

AI, Access, and Uptime: VMS’s Next Chapter with David Prusinski

VMS’s new Co-CEO, David Prusinski, shares how an AI-first approach will give small fleets and repair shops the tools to compete like big players.

Read More →
Photo of tire tracks and winter scenes.
Small FleetMay 24, 2025

Fleet Managers Share Winter Prep Tips: It's Never Too Early!

Three fleets share best practices to prep vehicles for winter and prevent downtime when the cold sets in.

Read More →
Ad Loading...
A thermometer with a high reading, and traffic behind it on a hot day. Words say the title of the article "Hot Weather Driving Tips for Fleet Drivers: 2025 Edition."
Small Fleetby Judie NuskeyMay 22, 2025

Hot Weather Driving Tips for Fleet Drivers

As we head into another potentially extreme summer season, the risks for fleet drivers remain high, from engine strain and tire blowouts to unpredictable traffic patterns. An expert shares advice on how fleet drivers can boost their safety during the steamy summer months.

Read More →