Work Truck Logo
MenuMENU
SearchSEARCH

Study Shows Only 57% of Contractors Report Vehicle Accidents

New data published reveals that contractors still see significant impacts to their projects and businesses due to fleet operation and maintenance.

August 15, 2023
Study Shows Only 57% of Contractors Report Vehicle Accidents

More than half find that these issues lead to productivity declines and increased insurance costs, while more than one third experience schedule delays and profitability declines.

Photo: Motive/Work Truck

2 min to read


A new study finds contractors can benefit from safer fleet operations, including productivity and profitability gains.

The study exposes the impacts that contractors experience from safety challenges in the operation and maintenance of their vehicles and equipment, and it reveals opportunities for deploying technology to address them. 

Ad Loading...

New data published by Dodge Construction Network, in partnership with Motive, reveals that contractors still see significant impacts to their projects and businesses due to the operation and maintenance of their fleets of vehicles and equipment.

The data comes from “The Safety on the Move: Automated Fleet Management and the Future of Safety for Contractors.”

Key findings include:

  • Vehicles: Accidents and near-misses are reported by 57% of contractors. More than half find that these issues lead to productivity declines and increased insurance costs, while more than one third experience schedule delays and profitability declines.

  • Equipment: While accidents and near misses for equipment are reported by fewer contractors (27%), they more frequently result, i.e. negative impacts on productivity and schedule. In fact, 60% of those who experience them link them directly to a decline in profitability on their projects.

  • Maintenance: 66% of contractors also experience safety issues due to the need for improved fleet maintenance, including both vehicles and equipment.

Streamlining and Supervising in Fleet

The research also uncovers a significant opening for contractors to streamline the monitoring and supervising their fleet safety through automation.

Ad Loading...

The results demonstrate that while 76% of contractors oversee vehicle safety and 62% monitor driver behavior, most still use physical forms or spreadsheets for these tasks.

Merely a quarter (25%) have automated the collection of driver behavior data, and an even smaller fraction (18%) have automated their fleet safety tracking.

Similar patterns emerge in fleet maintenance, where only a quarter (25%) incorporate automation or AI to facilitate management processes.

However, the study highlights that 80% of those employing technology in this aspect witness enhanced safety levels in their projects.

“Too often, safety is seen as a compliance requirement and not what it really is: a key element of a company’s operations that benefits the bottom line, and more importantly protects people, property and reputation,” says Abhishek Gupta, vice president of Product for Fleet Management at Motive. “The improved working conditions, efficiency, and cost savings that come with making safety a priority mean it should be a primary consideration for any business operating in the physical economy.”

The Power of Predictive Analytics: Turning Data into Decisions

More Safety

Work Truck “Trucks, Tips & Tours” promotional graphic featuring a vocational truck approaching a crash-test vehicle, highlighting Detroit Assurance collision mitigation technology with the headline “Collision Mitigation Explained.”
Safetyby Wayne ParhamJuly 21, 2026

How Detroit Assurance with Active Brake Assist Works

Do you want to see what it is like to experience Detroit Assurance’s Active Brake Assist? In this video, Work Truck will put you in the cab to see how it all works and then hear more details from DTNA’s Mike Young.

Read More →
Black graphic with large white text reading “Stop Workplace Violence” framed by blue accent lines.
SafetyJuly 21, 2026

Get Left of Loss: A 5-Step Workplace Prevention Framework for Fleet Operators

Violence risks do not stop at the driver’s door. Learn five practical steps fleets can take to spot threats early and protect workers before loss occurs.

Read More →
Promotional graphic for a Utilimarc guide titled How Better Visibility Cut Speeding Violations by 48% featuring a call-to-action to download the guide.
SponsoredJuly 17, 2026

How Better Visibility Cut Speeding Violations by 48%

Fleet leaders don't need more data, they need clearer visibility into what the data is saying. This case study explores how one utility replaced speeding-event counts with a single metric — miles driven in violation — to strengthen safety and significantly reduce speeding violations.

Read More →
Ad Loading...
Commercial truck driver wearing a red seat belt smiles from the driver’s seat of a blue truck.
Safetyby StaffJuly 15, 2026

13 Safe Driving Tips for Commercial Vehicle Drivers

Make sure you are spending time on the road safely with these important tips.

Read More →
Pavement background with double yellow lines and large text that says Recall, July, and Work Truck logo.
Safetyby Wayne ParhamJuly 10, 2026

Recalls You Need to Know About in July 2026

If you have Altec, Ford, General Motors, Harbinger, Hyundai, Mack Trucks, or Volvo Trucks vehicles in your fleet, you should check these important recalls issued by the National Highway Safety Administration.

Read More →
Illustration of a human hand reaching toward a robotic hand over an aerial view of a city at dusk, with interconnected location pins and network lines symbolizing AI, telematics, connected fleet technology, and data-driven transportation.
SafetyJuly 6, 2026

How Telematics Is Transforming Fleet Risk from Insight to Action

What if you could spot risky driving before it leads to a crash? See how telematics is still changing fleet safety today.

Read More →
Ad Loading...
View from inside a commercial truck cab showing a driver at the wheel with a large marijuana leaf overlaid by a red prohibition symbol, illustrating DOT restrictions on marijuana use for commercial drivers.
Safetyby Kathy CloseJuly 2, 2026

DOT Rules Remain Firmly Lit on Marijuana

DOT says not so fast on marijuana. Even with federal reclassification efforts, commercial drivers in safety-sensitive roles remain subject to marijuana testing and prohibitions.

Read More →
LytxOne promotional graphic featuring an in-cab dash camera and icons representing analytics, search, recording, video, reporting, driver performance, fuel, and location. Headline reads, “New Features Available Now.”
Safetyby News/Media ReleaseJuly 1, 2026

Lytx Adds Fleet Management Enhancements to LytxOne Platform

Lytx has added new features to LytxOne to bring safety, operational insight, asset visibility, and compliance into a unified, all-in-one platform.

Read More →
A shadowed figure removes cargo boxes from the back of a delivery van at night while fireworks explode in the background. Text overlay reads, "Before the Fireworks Start Review Your Cargo Security Plan."
Safetyby Lauren FletcherJune 23, 2026

A Fourth of July Cargo Theft Reality Check for Fleet Managers

The Fourth of July creates prime conditions for cargo theft. Here's what fleet managers should review now to protect loads, drivers and operations.

Read More →
Ad Loading...
Behind the Article thumbnail featuring Kathy Close of J.J. Keller. The image shows a road at sunset with bold text reading, “Do You Know What’s Driving Up Your CSA Score?” alongside Kathy Close discussing how fleets can use FMCSA's DataQs system to challenge inaccurate safety data and protect CSA scores.
Safetyby Lauren FletcherJune 19, 2026

What is DataQs and Why Should Fleets Care?

Watch to learn how FMCSA's DataQs system helps fleets challenge inaccurate safety data, protect CSA scores, and improve compliance records.

Read More →