The Number 1 Resource for Vocational Truck Fleets

Vehicle Research

Lightweighting: Less is More

May 2016, Work Truck - Feature

by Greg Thompson

A time-tested way to save money has long been to do the same job with a lighter vehicle. When done properly, reducing poundage in small to medium trucks via lightweighting can improve fuel efficiency, reduce wear-and-tear, and boost available payload.

With a pull-out shelf, such as the Katerack or Durarac, Dejana provides drivers with a lightweight option for easy access to their tools and equipment. (PHOTO: Dejana)
With a pull-out shelf, such as the Katerack or Durarac, Dejana provides drivers with a lightweight option for easy access to their tools and equipment. (PHOTO: Dejana)

The trick, according to Kevin Trainor, director of sales at Dejana Truck and Utility Equipment Companies, is to know what clients truly need. “Qualification of the customer is important,” said Trainor, a veteran of more than four decades in the truck business. “If you sell a fleet manager an aluminum dump body, it’s always best to know what it’s intended use and the expected payload will be.”

For those who are not going to “abuse” their trucks, Trainor confirmed that lighter alloys, such as aluminum, have become much tougher and stronger and are trending on the medium-duty side. “There are also some companies coming up with a honeycomb panel for a side wall in a van,” Trainor added. “For a full-size van, that will be lighter per square foot than a fiberglass reinforced plywood (FRP) wall. At Dejana, we are being asked to build a traditional body, which is either FRP or an aluminum sheet and post version.”

Dejana accommodates the steel-to-aluminum interior trend with its proprietary Katerack and DuraRack interiors.

“People have downsized from ¾-ton vans to ½-ton pickups (Ford F-150 or GM/Ram 1500 series). Another recent development was the designing of a 1500 GM chassis that a lightweight service body could be installed on. This gives the potential of going to a smaller motor, something that gets better fuel economy, can carry more people, and offer the option of four-wheel drive. Pickups can also be upfitted with work caps or toppers ,such as the KnapKap. This lightweight fiberglass cap goes over the bed of the truck and can have side access doors and shelving for easy storage of equipment tools.”

Fueling Efficiency

Adrian Steel uses a variety of materials in its design such as steel shelving; composite partitions; and composite parts, cases, and bins. The ladder rack is all aluminum. (PHOTO: Adrian Steel)
Adrian Steel uses a variety of materials in its design such as steel shelving; composite partitions; and composite parts, cases, and bins. The ladder rack is all aluminum. (PHOTO: Adrian Steel)

Despite lower fuel costs, lightweighting continues to feed the familiar trend toward fuel efficiency, but efficiency in time spent per job is also high on the list.

Unnecessary storage equipment not only adds weight, it adds extra time spent looking for tools. Todd Goldmeyer, marketing manager, national fleets at Adrian Steel Company, has seen the cargo vans filled to the ceiling, making it difficult for technicians to quickly find what they need.

“Just think, if they could find that piece of inventory 5, 10, or 15 minutes faster,” Goldmeyer said. “We work with fleets to identify workflow, cargo, and how often they need that cargo. That allows us to design a solution around their needs. It’s not only lightweighting, but also having the right amount of inventory and making access to the inventory more efficient.”

The fleet business is built around efficiency, with fleet managers trying to “wring every dollar of profit out of their operations,” according to Greg Randolph, vice president of marketing at Decked.
In response, Decked “created a product that is really durable and very light in weight, but heavy in duty,” Randolph said.

Specifically, the company’s in-vehicle storage and organization system is made of high-density polyethylene with a galvanized steel subframe structure.

“It’s an engineered product designed to give you payload capacity without compromising overall payload capacity of the vehicle,” Randolph explained. “Decked drops into your truck and weighs between 200 and 220 pounds. It is capable of carrying 2,000 pounds. Also, it’s not a special build. Our products fit every full-size truck and van made since the late 1990s. An experienced installer can put in a Decked system in 90 minutes, because there is no need to alter the vehicle.”

Considering All Variables

One lightweight upfit offered by BrandFX incudes a standard 9-foot Telecom Aerial Body with Top Box and Tailshelf Option and Versalift Tel29 aerial apparatus. (PHOTO: BrandFX)
One lightweight upfit offered by BrandFX incudes a standard 9-foot Telecom Aerial Body with Top Box and Tailshelf Option and Versalift Tel29 aerial apparatus. (PHOTO: BrandFX)

Whether it’s relatively quick and easy, or more involved, any commitment to lightweighting or rightsizing a fleet will involve time and money. Carla Anglin, vice president of sales and marketing at BrandFX Body Company, noted that the right decision depends on looking at all the variables.

“Within the work truck industry, the trend is primarily rightsizing the chassis — reducing the weight of equipment via composites and aluminum, telematics, and management of daily loads,” Anglin said. “Rightsizing the chassis encompasses load management, lighter equipment, and spec’ing trucks strategically for specific jobs, rather than having a fleet of all-around work trucks. These are all tactics for accomplishing efficiency.”

In previous eras, fleet managers may have been unwilling to make changes, but not anymore.

“I would attribute this to oil prices,” Anglin said. “Although we’re in a slump, everyone expects prices to go back as high as we’ve seen them in 2007. The other driver would be the CAFE standards.”

When fuel prices went up, the BrandFX selling proposition changed to meet market demand — shifting from corrosion resistance and longer lifecycle to weight reduction and fuel and maintenance savings. And, the shift may well be permanent. “Gone are the days of ‘bigger is better’ and ‘steel tough.’ They were misnomers, anyway,” Anglin said.

Current lightweight offerings at BrandFX include standard under-structures made of aluminum or sometimes steel. The material lends itself well to the flexing and bending of aerial or under-structures applications, as well as high corrosive environments.

“We have composite applications that are able to flex a full 33 degrees on center without incurring any damage,” Anglin said. “If you can imagine the stress applied across a metal body during use of an aerial apparatus, you can see how that flexibility would be beneficial and extend lifecycle.”

BrandFX recently used its experience in composite applications to effectively move fleets from a Ford F-450 to F-350 chassis with light aerial applications — keeping 2600 pounds of workable payload by using a composite body with aluminum under-structures. And, the effects were noticeable.

“A large national fleet utilizing our 60CA composite body for aerial applications tracked their overall miles-per-gallon across their fleet to be 8 mpg on their lightweight body specification chassis versus 5 mpg on steel body applications,” Anglin said.

While admitting a certain bias, Anglin believes composite is the right answer virtually every time due to its strength-to-weight ratio and corrosion-free service.

“I predict more composites manufacturers will come into the market and that lightweight steel, magnesium, and aluminum will continue to increase,” she said. “Aluminum is by far the easier material for most manufacturers to adapt to; however, I do not believe it fits all applications. Composite is more durable and versatile, but it is a very challenging manufacturing process for a startup line. For both reasons, I expect aluminum and composite will own the future space of lightweight materials.”

Ensuring Legal Compliance

Additional reasons for “going lighter” inevitably include legal concerns.

“Particularly among fleets operating vehicles over 10,000 pounds, compliance and liability are legitimate concerns,” noted Joe Foster, national fleet sales manager at Auto Truck Group. “An overweight truck taking longer to brake, and potentially causing an accident is a serious liability that fleets don’t want to encounter,” he said.

Foster added that most fleet managers involved in weight analysis are also looking at long-term marketability at resale, and usually only when changing to a different OEM or chassis specification.

“If the lightweight components don’t exceed a premium of 20 to 25% over existing components, fleets have been more inclined to make lightweighting a priority,” he said.

The lightweighting process can pay dividends, according to Foster, particularly because service technicians are gradually taking on more job functions, while their vehicle remains the same.

“Technicians have added tools, parts, and equipment to perform all job functions. The challenge is understanding what parts and tools are really necessary to do the job and assess what equipment is needed to carry those parts and tools,” he explained.

According to Foster, the second-largest challenge is the migration to procurement-driven fleet decisions.

“Lightweight typically costs more, but may save the overall fleet in increased fuel economy, reduced maintenance, and potential liability. Understanding the operational benefits do not make it into the front-end financial considerations, but typically in the procurement decision methodology,” he said.

Companies looking to make relatively small adjustments may consider changing from metal to poly fenders, a change that Jacob Peterson, outside sales for National Fleet Products said can make an immediate impact.

“If they can take 200 pounds off in metal fenders, and put 100 pounds back on with poly, they save 100 pounds, and they can haul 100 more pounds of payload,” Peterson said. “That’s the payoff.”  

Customizing Concerns

With so many variables to consider, Brad Anderson, regional sales manager, Ranger Design Inc., stressed the importance of customization in any lightweighting effort.

“Whether it’s aluminum or steel, which would be a heavier option, it is highly customizable,” Anderson said. “We have a ton of options. People are looking to get the most out of their van, so they need to customize it to what their specific task is in that van, and the different products they are storing in it.”

Beyond the lightweight question, customization is a bigger one. “The other consideration is longevity,” he said.

“Not all composites are created equal, so yes it’s light, but is it going to last as long, has it been engineered properly? It comes back to crash testing, which is a good indicator of how good the product is. Until you actually start asking the right questions, you can’t really tell the difference,” Anderson noted. “The misunderstanding about lightweight is that it is weak. Take an aluminum product versus a steel product. Aluminum can be twice as strong by weight. You have to use a thicker material to get the same strength as steel, but it will be much lighter.”

Whether using aluminum or composites, many vocational truck fleets, and large fleets such as telecoms, are beginning to look at the whole truck upfit, not only the truck body.

Fleet managers are leaning toward lower GVWR chassis to address concerns about licensing requirements, driver reporting, and internal pressures to improve fuel efficiency, productivity, and safety, according to Eric McNally, VP, sales & business development at Reading Equipment & Distribution.

“The lighter chassis requires a lighter vocational body upfit to be able to maintain capacity requirements,” McNally said. “Chassis OEMs are seeing this same pressure, and we are seeing increased use of lighter weight materials in both light- and medium-duty products.”

While there are multiple lightweight materials to use for vocational truck upfits, aluminum is again a popular solution because it is lightweight, inherently corrosive resistant, and easily recyclable. In line with this demand, Reading offers open utility/service bodies, as well as enclosed service vans.

“Through our company-owned upfit group, we also offer the organizational solutions that the industry demands,” McNally said. “Van interiors and pickup trucks are turning to aluminum for racks, bins, and shelving, as well as toolboxes. And, still the industry needs to overcome the common misconception that lighter weight means ‘light duty.’ Aluminum is a very strong and durable material, all the way from lighter gauge doors and shelving systems to the heavy-duty under-structures. One of the ways Reading is able to educate the marketplace is to back its aluminum products with a 10-year structural warranty.” 

Comments

  1. 1. Andrew Halonen [ May 17, 2016 @ 10:45AM ]

    This is a very good article that covered many of the aspects of light-weighting, with exception to volumes and prior CAPEX. If a shop has a lot of steel laser cutting & welding, it will be reluctant to move to a non-ferrous material or a composite. And, customization usually means low volumes that may not justify tooling on a casting.

  2. 2. [email protected] [ June 13, 2016 @ 07:13AM ]

    This has been out for a few weeks now but you probably haven't seen it and may be interested. The reporter approached Carla at one of the recent trade shows. The article has been trending pretty highly at worktruckonline.com for a few weeks now.

 

Comment On This Story

Name:  
Email:  
Comment: (Maximum 10000 characters)  
Leave this field empty:
* Please note that every comment is moderated.

FleetFAQ

Fleet Management And Leasing

Merchants Experts will answer your questions and challenges

View All

Fleet Incentives

Determine the actual cost of owning and running a vehicle in your fleet. Compare vehicles by class and model.

Lifecycle Costs Analyzer

Determine the actual cost of owning and running a vehicle in your fleet. Compare vehicles by class and model.

Sponsored by

Personal Navigation Device.

Read more